Well I might have slightly misunderstood what you had asked me to do in regards to how intuitive the game is but I think as someone who knows how Mario Party works the game would make immediate sense in regards to what its doing and why. I didn't play online just the story till Chapter 1, for the most part I thought it was a nice enough party game to play with friends,
The UI, Music and sfx all of it is plenty well done, there were a few bits of issues in regards to the actual Tutorial game though since the Dialogue there covers the gameplay options too, like in regards to where you would like to go directions wise. It also has its own UI error where the button hint is being covered by the "Got It" sign. And there was one or two dialogue options that didn't have this sign so went away before I could read it.
All the Minigames, I played were intuitive enough, for some reason I thought you wanted me to play them without reading the instructions to just get a feel for how understandable they are which I did do and i understood what I had to do in most of them. I just didn't read the button inputs in most of them too, so didn't win those a lot of times. Also the only game that felt kinda off was the Anchor chain jump one, not sure why there was such a delay on that one, and no feedback too in regards to what I was clicking.
I don't have as much to say about the Story since I didn't read that far into it but it seemed okaish, I imagine that the multiplayer aspect would be the priority for mostly all the players. I am sure I could get my friends to play this for a fun game night.
I think that's about all my thoughts on the game. Good luck for future development.

Undaex
Creator of
Recent community posts
I did complete the demo completely so that means the game was fun enough, it goes go well with the Spore idea, and the making your own type of Cell with its own special quirks and stuff is nice too. The game did struggle a bit running on the browser though so did have a few lag spikes randomly and also cases where the fishes loaded would randomly just disappear . That happened most in the Reef not sure if that's somewhat intentional or not, could be since those ones looked way different and bigger then anything else.
For the most part I did just swim around for a while as much as I could and didn't even realise the tasks option was there, and that I was supposed to actually follow what it said. A lot of the UI indicators like that didn't seem like they were that important and could probably be just ignored and you would still be fine. So all the rival bits and other things, they didn't seem like it affected things that much, since progression was mainly tied to eating more.
As for the random effects that were happening, other than the Swarm one I don't think others were that consequential like maybe the Sun one, but that area far too small to pose any sort of threat and I don't remember any of the other ones doing anything. The huge organism one was kinda odd too since I wasn't sure if I was actually consuming it or not.
For the upgrades bit, you definitly need indicators for what power needs how many slots, if that was already there, then I didn't realise it at all. Another thing is for the similarly named affects so like the faster jet ones, one costs more but I am not really sure how much of a improvement that actually would be, so some sort of stats sheet which shows how much of a difference each thing could make. Also like you can stack powers, I made a biblically accurate angel for one of the generations, though I don't think stacking those made a difference in the visibility.
The fact that after dying you can control the previous generation is nice enough too, though I am not sure how good they were at surviving since a lot of the time they would be randomly dead, but thats probably because I was constantly trying to bite into the big all sides shielded one , I don't think it ever actually worked not really sure what to do for that. Maybe if I use the abilities then that's possible to damage them. I didn't really choose any of the active abilities since just floating around worked nicely enough for the most part.
I think that was mostly everything I could think of. Good luck for the future development.
For the most part the game is fun, the highest I reached was like the 5th stage with the Trigate thingies and they destroyed me quite easily for sure. I played for long enough I think but the controls still felt like kinda stiff, like not as smooth as I would like them to be though I imagine that is intentional enough for the gameplay difficulty.
For the most part the game does everything nicely enough, you said the tutorial was considered too hard, but it wasn't really that bad I think. The hitting two ships using the boost took a few attempts and for the most part I don't think that's necessarily that important for the player to know either since I don't think they would really need to do that that often.
For the regular game feel the sfx was nice enough I would say, kinda loud at times though, music did get repetitive enough after a while and I don't think the Options had an option between the two. That would probably be nice to have. The TTS worked fine too since it fit into the setting and focused up a bit on the Dialogue that I might have missed otherwise.
The difficulty wasn't really as bad I would say since its expected that you die enough times and so for the most part with time you should be able steamroll anything difficult enough and the Upgrades were all nice enough too the ones you get as Augments since it made actual gameplay difference. One bad thing i would say is that the upgrades should really be only for the weapons you have, I got a laser upgrade a few times and I thought it would get added to the ship for that run but apparently not so I imagine it was a different weapon which I didn't unlock yet.
Also for the multi equip thingy, I feel like if you have made the option of they could fire together, then maybe there should be a toggle that is so that they could be connected to the same mouse input, since pressing both the mouse buttons together feels off. I am sure strategy wise, having two firing at different times would be useful so that's why just a toggle to let the player choose.
I think thats about everything I could think of. Good luck for the future development.
Well if I was a petty man I would have tried playing till I beat your time score, and I was but still failed anyhow. No idea if you keep track of number of attempts but I made several for sure didn't work out. Drift was out of question when the high score was like 90000 but time one felt like it could be beatable for a bit. I think there was one place where going off road is faster then the regular but I couldn't get it to work again
Now for the actual game, the game is very much an early prototype so for the most part it doesn't really have its own identity as of now due to which it could be considered actually different. Not really sure what that could actually be consider how the racing genre is but if you play enough which I assume you do then I am sure you could figure that out.
Music is something I am sure you would get to eventually, but some things do need more proper sfx to like the combo meter in the drift race which corresponds to how the number is going up. The UI is something that also would require a lot of changing because right now, it feels like you are using the default options for mostly everything.
One glitch that I did find was that if you press R to respawn that doesn't fix the roadblocks and they remain as they did before in the previous attempt. Another thing about the roadblocks is that I feel that once they are hit they should probably break or maybe get reset when its in air because a lot of times, a block you had hit way back would just fall down the mountain in front of your path which doesn't feel fair.
There are a lot more quality of life things that you have to add that basically all racing games do have which does just comes down to stuff like the Map and the Speedometer and others things that I am sure you know better than I do.
I think that's about everything I could think of. Good luck in future development.
Thanks a lot, all this information is very much helpful and I will try to figure out how I can use this to make the game better. For some of the things you have mentioned I can think of very clear solutions, so for the selecting seeds and harvesting fruits bit just needs some visual indication for that and it would be enough. The Black Infection bit is also something that I could kinda make more visually clear of what is removable and what not, but as for the Tutorial as it states that was just the simulated version of the Nezarot and not the actual thing.
As for the Seed placement bit, its not like the player has to figure out which seed is for what everytime since the seeds are divided in a manner that indicates which seedbed they belong to. Atleast that was the idea behind it, that players would realize it after the first day or two, originally the game didn't have this but I just added this into the loop for a bit more complexity in how you approach the Tree.
I am curious in regards to the Growth Stages since I was hoping that the progress bar that was besides it was a clear enough indicator to the fact that it was now in a different stage.
Now focusing onto your final point of what the player should be doing at any given moment, I think it just comes down to what they feel is right at the moment so it could be any of the things you mentioned. The only two considerations for it would be that the Tree isn't fully consumed and that you reach your target and however you do that is fine. Atleast that's my idea for what it should be.
The White Plastic Sky bit is something that is surprisingly similar to the themes and vibes I am going for. I had never heard of it before but I did see the trailer just now and it looks quite interesting, I will look more into it and see where it goes could help a bit in making my own world.
My bad if I come off a bit aggressive when you are only trying to help, truly didn't mean to do that. Your observations have really been helpful and I will see how I can make the game better based on everything you have said.
This game definitely blew away all my expectations based on the description you gave me but this is some really great work. On a gameplay level, I am sure you have a bit more work to do but in terms of the atmosphere of the game, you have really nailed the vibe even with the placeholder assets you are using. I did the full tutorial, and two runs of the Manor one which went on the standard manor and the other which went through the Gardens. On a technical level, I don't think I learnt much about the actual Manor, but it hits the uncanny fantastical vibes that I am a really big fan of.
In terms of actual mechanics, I do like the choose your own adventure style dice roles where a lot of things don't really go your way but you can risk it for knowing more about the World. I would like you to add some choices that unlike the dice roles do guarantee your choice but would just affect the stats directly like how it works in case of Stamina. Maybe it does work like that in some other places, but stamina was the only place I actually noticed this. But considering failing these checks usually isn't a run ended that's not as bad and more like you just get sucked deeper into a different rabbit hole.
The combat mechanics on the other hand may need a bit more agency from the player. For the most part I didn't really think I needed to change the player from the Normal Style since it was balanced enough compared to the Aggressive one where the only reason you would do that is if the enemy was just slightly above your usual damage range. Not sure why you would use the Defense builds at all, but there are more charms and benefits that prop up later on which from the looks of things is highly likely, I do kinda like the idea of just dying because you are just too weak in front of otherwordly horrors though. In the garden, I ran away from the Crow Knight, running away usually did seem like the smarter option in a lot of fights. And then just facing a statue of otherwordly horrors that one shot me anyhow. That was great.
I do think the Tutorial prologue isn't nearly as interesting but that's probably because it is still in very normalish world that kinda follows the rules, and you still have to establish the baseline setting.Not really sure how you could possibly balance both of those together, but probably your best bet would just be that the player just perseveres through till the game actually gets interesting.
Two more things, probably shouldn't call going back to the settings as Open the Book, thats just confusing and I sure didn't realize that for a while. Other thing was that I found a typo on the Two Corridors, Neither Right where it should say "can't help but". I am sure you can figure out where that is.
That's about all my thoughts on the game, I hope you are able to get an actual artist for the art of the game because with that I am sure you could make this really big. Good luck in making more of this.
I played like 7 runs till I got like a 40000 score and an S rank, so I imagine I have more or less experienced mostly everything the game had to offer in terms of enemies and mechanics.
Considering how the game is I suppose it doesn't really need a proper tutorial and for the most part the player could just go about and figure there way through while clicking anything that glows and they would be fine. The how to play certainly doesn't help at the start but the name of the things atleast does kinda stick around so makes more sense later.
I tried both the Turret and the Laser, started with the Turret lost basically instantly but got some of the Etch points which I didn't really understand at the time, went to the Tree and clicked everything that was glowing. Tried again basically died at the seemingly the same spot again, upgraded the Tree again still wasn't reading as much for the things were but randomly I bought the extra turrets so once they started auto aiming the other side, that was enough for me to reach the Second Boss and die there. After that I started actually reading what the Tree upgrades were and the gave made way more sense in terms of what I should do. Still not sure what the BIOS Bolt thing is though.
The gameplay and aesthetic is nice enough for the most part and I liked to see the score number go up, not sure if my 4000 chain combo was already calculated though since I feel like the score should be way higher if it was.
I played the Laser after I was able to beat the Second Boss with the Turrets and basically took all the points from that to fully upgrade the Laser and was able to reach the final score at the Top. I am not really sure how significant the upgrades of beating the boss were in the game, since for the most part I don't think it made that much of a difference. I am also not always sure how I am taking damage since the last time I don't think any enemies were particularly close but maybe some of them do throw projectiles and I just never really realized since too much happening on screen at that point.
That is about everything I could think, a very turn your head off and see numbers go up game, which I guess is nice enough for an incremental game. Good luck in making more things.
I am not really a fan of the generic AI generated artstyle that you have chosen but still decided to play the game till I died once which happened against the Ronin who I fought in like somewhat low health but maybe could have beaten if I got lucky with the sword charm.
For the most part the idea of direction is nice enough and manga based story telling probably could work great. The voice acting too is like okaish, in some cases it does go kinda bad where it doesn't hit the appropriate emotional beat but it does work well when the character is supposed to be just acting cool.
Gameplay wise, it is a normal enough card based deck building game. I haven't played something like Slay the Spire before so I don't really know what the peak of that is supposed to be, but if we are basing this purely on the game itself it does everything it needs to. The UI and Powers are clear for what they do, I am not sure if anything more complicated would come up later on though. One thing that I didn't really understand was the Exhaust since no real sign popped up for that one but I imagine it is some kind of debuff on the player making him do less damage or take more damge.
Difficulty wise I think its fine for the most part, once or twice losing around would make the player understand what to do or in other cases you can just choose to heal more often, so atleast till the part I played it works fine.
That's about everything I have in mind. If I had to choose something that needs priority in changing it would be to make the AI generated art feel less generic and make it follow a better looking style that isn't so generic. Good luck making more stuff.
The game is for sure very fun and I spent way longer on it then I probably should have, I reached like Night 18 but was more or less stuck in terms of story progress I made which is quite sad. It was something along the lines of Restore a Wonder, I am not really sure what that actually meant, I assumed it was an actual building but I didn't really find anything that I think would have been termed as a Wonder, maybe the Tower right besides the start but didn't look like I could do much with it. I read more and then it mentioned Roast Fish so i thought that was the wonder it was referring to but I don't think I unlocked that in the Cooking recipes either so not sure what that happened.
The artstyle, gameplay and music are all really well done and matches the aesthetic nicely enough. As for the actual story, I am not as sure about what's happening in that but its certainly not intrusive enough in the gameplay to halt the flow of things, maybe I would have understood more of it, if I didn't get stuck.
There are some issues I might have in the UI in terms of food and freezing since in most cases I never really notice it at all until the character mentions it which for the most part does work fine enough but maybe it being bigger would help. Same applies to the side inventory of the things like Logs and Stones though in that case I always just open the Main Inventory so its not as much an issue.
Now the actual combat and the characters of the game, well in a lot of time I wasn't as sure of what I or they were doing. I don't know if I actually missed it but I didn't really how to actually hit the enemies in the beginning, had to press through all keys to find which was the attack button. I am not sure what the Frost shards do either, I think its just for knockback when near the fire but I could be wrong. I don't do base building games as much so I am not really sure how much of a crunch I am supposed to be in but for the most part the time of day is definitely way too short to the point I did just stop making any sort of defense for the base and would just fight the enemies head on, considering I reached like Night 18, clearly that was working a bit too well.
Also for some reason when I was looking for the Wonder as a building I found another campsite and made a bed there, and asking the guy to move in didn't really work. I am not really sure how you are supposed to move bases because for the most part even when beds were broken other two seemed fine. I never tried sleeping in the game but I imagine its not like Minecraft to skip the Night and the day was already far too small to try that. The day being small also meant I couldn't go much in either direction but I did try and considering how that wasn't instant death, it was nice that I could still run back immediately.
I am sure the game has way more stuff that I didn't even reach yet but its still engaging enough that I played it for so long even when stuck. So thats pretty good. Good luck making more of this.
So I picked the Deserter and chose to roam the lands, and survived till like Day 10, and then went into a place knowing that I would likely die since I wanted a good place to end my playthrough. For starters this isn't the type of game I would actually play, since I usually care for a proper narratively driven game and this feels more like carving out my own story. Maybe there is a central narrative in the background, I didn't as much figure it out while playing.
Most of the UI and sound bits are nice enough for the most part, while the visuals probably definitely need more work. Even without considering the AI artstyle, there were a lot of visual errors in the game, like how the character was missing half its arm in its portrait or how he was carrying a comically large spear that doesn't actually fit in hand. There is also one case where I saw a head that's not really of the same body and looks more like it has been blended into that.
The only game I have played in this style of combat is the final fantasy tactics game, and the combat here leaves much to be desired since for the most part I don't think anything other than levels would dictate the combat or strategy since your choices are limited enough. At first I didn't like how you couldn't undo your movement but considering how moving allows for a free attack that does kinda makes sense. So maybe some more options could help in that. It is possible that it already exists in the game and I simply never reached that point but as it stands I didn't find the combat fun, since for the most part I didn't feel like I needed to strategize as much.
There were a few times where I wasn't really sure why I couldn't do something like I wanted to make my companion Fenna as the healer and the game told me she was the best for it but I couldn't select her not sure why maybe I could click the tutorial guy and he would have told me but I didn't try that.
I think the Tutorial itself is pretty clear, like it does tell the important stuff as is needed and then introduces the lesser things as they come up. It did feel like a lot of reading though but I guess that would come down to all the options that the game already has. I imagine if I continued the playthrough normally, I would have more decisions that would make it like my own story and I would get be a Lone Hero or maybe become the Ruler itself, but not really a fan of things like that but probably there is a significant enough audience for that type of game.
That is about everything that I could think of. good luck on improving your game further.
Maybe I should get more people be mentally exhausted before making them play the game because all of this is plenty useful. Glad you like the style and vibes of the game. I will see how I can improve upon each of your points.
For the tree tutorial and the whole tree in general, I suppose it would make more sense to go forward as the stage of concern for the tree increases where the music would get more tense the longer you have been planting which would probably work better then being that tense throughout.
I would like you to explain the counterintuitive part more though whenever you give the game another shot. The tree gameplay is something I am very curious about because as it stands I am not really sure how good it actually at a base level. I have started to add on a bit onto it, but probably best to secure the base first, so any thoughts you have about it would help out a lot.
For some bits I guess you did miss some dialogues like in regards to the Fruits being gone but yeaa the Seed one isn't as directly acknowledged. Will make changes to make some more of the UI things clear too, hopefully it would make more sense then.
Either way thank you for giving the game a shot even once.
I reached like the 9th in Abyss and got stuck, like couldn't find the way further. I would assume I have to go through this hole but maybe the collision isn't set as right because I sure couldn't do it no matter how much I tried. But I do know its possible since a Centipede did do it, and I don't think there was any other paths since I did circle around quite a number of times.
As for the game itself, its great. The movement is great, the sonar is great and the enemy design all seems great. The gameplay itself does maybe need to be a bit more punishing just considering the fact that I never really died in the game but I did get close sometimes but was able to full heal the next time anyhow. The game was able to scare me a few times though whenever something would fall from the ceiling that was nice. The Spiders, I think as enemy should probably be a bit more threatening considering I think they are the only ones I never really took damage too, maybe the hunter one could have a bit more of a quicker shot and the whip one would have more of a range.
In a lot of cases, when I am just at the middle of the caves I think I am a bit too safe, but also those are times when something falling from the sky is most terrifying so maybe there is a balance that's needed.
The balance would also maybe make the pebbles more useful since even though I did always collect them I don't think I ever really needed them much except maybe the boss fights but even them it didn't seem like they could do much. Also atleast in the second Centipede Mother fight I could just cheese it by going near the resonance stone and it just standing there, not sure if that's by design could work nicely for some people who do figure it out maybe.
The issue that came up most in regards to the game was essentially that as the Map got bigger the fireflies got harder to find and I just spent a lot of time looping around with no way forward. In the beginning atleast, I got all of them but by the time I reached the Abyss finding them all was too much work. An arrow might be too much but maybe there would be some structure that could atleast point in the general direction of the fly when hit by the sonar could be nice.
Another important thing would be the abilities, I am not as sure about how much of a gameplay difference they made the full health one was basically the one i chose most. I got the wall sense one like near the end, didn't feel like it did much but I was stuck so maybe that different. The attracting fly one maybe worked usefully once or twice when there were too many enemies clogged up at one place which I didn't wanna go through, but maybe the radius could be increased a bit more for that. The enemy linger one definitely was way more harmful then it was useful since the enemies would move on and I would still be thinking they were just there for a bit longer then I should have. I can't remember any more of them but I suppose they do minor improvements in quality of life bits so its probably working as intended.
I think I covered just about everything, so yeaa, its a fun game. You are doing great. Good luck doing more great things.
Well I finished both the campaigns completely, did wipe out once on Act 1 at Day 10 when the horses first came. Other than that lost 1 life each time against the Boss at the end of both Acts, As you can see from how I finished the game completely, I found it quite fun. The gameplay was very nice and the enemies had enough variety to keep things interesting and the music went along nicely enough with how the game worked.
Now to some specific issues I had in the game, at the start of the game, the menu didn't really have any music or sfx which kinda seemed odd, initially i thought there was something wrong in the laptop audio but considering how the rest of the game does have it, I would assume you simply haven't reached that point yet.
I don't have as much to say about Act 1, the abilities and controls all worked nicely enough, i did think the horses kinda felt like they were coming from nowhere but with time I got more used to them still couldn't bow them all but atleast I felt like I had enough time to use the traps for them. So it worked nicely enough. And the boss was challenging enough too and the game had a healthy balance of difficulty.
Act 2 was very different and the Catapult is way too strong i think a lot of the later nights I could make it so that the enemies never even broke the Bridge and also the Catapult shouldn't be able to one shot the boss, that is way too strong, despite its strength it also didn't feel as right to use either because a lot of times swiping it, I would just trigger the normal arrows, so kinda clunky in that regard. Not sure if its a good idea but it probably does make more sense for this to be a one time ability like the Balista, since for the most part I didn't really use the fire arrows that much since Catapult dealt with the other catapult much better. And considering how the shield enemies would always kinda stop a bit far away from the wall I never really tried to burn them down much either. The potion and tar were nice enough ability wise, I didn't always use the Tar but the slow potion was useful enough even though in a lot of cases I didn't use it that optimally either.
In regards to the Stakes I think they should be visually clearer in regards to where they are located since the short arrow would usually always get hidden by the enemies, so maybe it can be more underground, that could work maybe.
There were some UI errors i noticed in the Act 2 battle screen in regards to both the potions and stakes where there is some clipping happening in regards to the text. The Manual and Auto option also had an error in its tooltip thingy where the text and background were in different colours making it hard to read. Also not sure if anyone would use it on Auto from a gameplay perspective since same as the other traps when use you it is important.
One Final thing that happened was that the game kinda glitched out a bit in the Night 14 end where the enemies were all dead but nothing was really happening after that, not sure if it was because something got hidden beyond the edge or something but I think in that one I had to wait till dawn for the game to progress.
I think that's about everything I can think of. Good job at the game, plenty fun it was. Good luck in making more things.
https://limewire.com/d/ulcsC#bEUrrTWscc
Near the End, nothing as much happens because I changed tabs for writing the comment so like 10 min of maybe just standing still there.
I am not entirely sure if this happened but I think you might have accidentally skipped the Tutorial right at the beginning of the game, which is why you got confused in regards to the Tree Mechanics but glad you managed to figure it out by Trial and Error. That also had a bit more explanation for the bits like the Fully Blacked out spots.
In regards to the music and atmosphere of the game, I suppose I should tone down the general oppressive nature of it, atleast in some areas. Kinda makes sense, I will see what I can do for that. Thank you for trying out my game.
This is easily the most interesting game I have played in the jam as of now, and I love how the gameplay feels. I definitely need to put in way more time to fully appreciate everything you have done though. I got the Inside Ending but considering there are atleast 8, I imagine I have way more choices in the game that I haven't found yet.
The aesthetic you are going for is really well done, even in the manner you hint at solutions feel very much on brand and feels less like a game over and more like a continue forward atleast in regards to how you are mailed for it sometimes.(Not sure if that would get old if you die too much at one section though, its possible).
The only issue I had was that overtime the glitchy texture definitely started to sting the eyes a bit, but thats likely a me specific issue and not a fault of the game especially since it does suit the game very well. I wish I had way more feedback and suggestions for how to improve but the game feels like it already nails what its trying to do.
You are doing great and good luck with making more things.
Just to clarify the Screenshot wasn't the part where the game crashed I just took that because I just found it funny how bad of a solution I was using for the Level. And the part where it crashed was definitely way worse then that. But yes its possible the crash happened because of something completely unrelated.
As for the 1000 number bit, if you do still want to stick to it then you probably need to find a way to incentivise players a bit more to actually give it a shot, not exactly sure how you could achieve that maybe a completionist sticker or achievement. It's not that I didn't understand I could have 9 numbers delivered at once, its just my focus was more on getting to the next level. So maybe this would depend from player to player and how they approach the game.
Either way good luck making your game.
As much as I would have liked to finish the game after dying 283 times i think that's not for me. Definite skill issue on my part, the game itself feels pretty good at what its trying to do. I stopped around the F--ktory region after dying to it around a 50 times or atleast it felt like it. Maybe I would come back for it later.
Gameplay wise I think all the controls and the way you tutorialise things is pretty nicely done. The trail is good too and does work in showcasing what went wrong and how. The music does get a bit repetitive after a while but I don't think i minded that as much when i was able to progress continously but kinda got on my nerves when I got stuck, make of that what you will.
The one bit I think you can improve is in regards to all the different mechanics you have planned in for the game, and when they show up. I understand not making things too much for a casual player, but mechanics such as the Jump circle feels like something that could show up way earlier and keep the gameplay still be fresh without adding in extra difficulty atleast before the first choice of paths you get between the Machinery and the other place. The jump mechanic is my only example because that's the only one i actually experienced but I saw a time one, and whatever you have in that F--ktory too.
From how the places are named and structured I would like to imagine you have somewhat of a story/lore planned out for the game and that sounds pretty nice. Good luck to you. I had fun minus near the end where I was preparing to throw the keyboard into the orbit.
So I played the game for a while and reached like the second part of level 6 around which the game crashed randomly. I am not sure why that happened if i had to guess maybe I overloaded the amount of things that Itch could comfortably display on the screen which is possible since I am pretty bad at these Automation type games. I will attach an image of how bad I am too.
Now onto the actual game. The game is very fun and intuitive so you could potentially give it to anyone and they would like it plenty since the game does essentially revolve around basic arithmetic. The Audio design is also pretty satisfying especially the sound of whenever the right number is flowing towards the center. And the controls and hotkeys all work well too so overall a very enjoyable experience.
Now to the some stuff I think needs some changing. The Initial language being in Russian is a bad idea since most of your players are going to be playing in English especially considering where the changing language option is on the Screen. When I booted up the game first, I didn't put the game in fullscreen so didn't actually see the language changing option clearly since that section was being covered by the Itch UI which showed all the different jams the game had been placed in. I initially went through what I thought was the options menu to find a language change option but didn't find anything and it was only by chance that I saw the option as I was going to close the game. That's the major thing.
Another suggestion I have is in regards to the Optional challenge thingy of each level. Making the player just wait till a 1000 feels kinda pointless, especially in a case where someone who is playing like me which is very badly would just have to wait for the number to get to 1000 which seems like no one would try it. I would say its better to make the optional one like exceedingly challenging instead of something that just takes a lot of time. I will add another thing in this point which is a fast forward button, which I imagine you can't do if your optional challenge is a 1000 things but you can if the additional challenge is something else.
This one is a possible feature which I am not really sure is good or not since I don't play these games as much, but possibly a method of limiting the amount of things you can do at a level. So like a "n" number of connectors each level or a money system how Polybridge does it where each things costs a certain bit of money. That could be fun.
One final off thing was sometimes when zoomed out fully a few chunks of numbers would near the corner of the screen. I think for the most part either they shouldn't be there since they aren't really needed for the level, but if you do want them there then it makes sense for them to be fully visible. Also I just remembered that the Separator operator doesn't have its own tutorial, I only figured out what it did near the end when i had to do the 666 puzzle, I think you unlock it at the same time as the Multiplier unless I missed something which is then entirely on me.
I think that's everything I could think of. I had fun, good job.
I did update the game and so that should have likely fixed the issue with the particles I think. There could be some stuff that I still missed out on. But yes as for the other stuff you mentioned, I did make like a more proper tutorial for the Game, so hopefully for the most part that does explain how the UI and the gameplay functions..
I am not entirely sure how you mean weird in regards to the Hall though, the only thing I can think of is like the second camera not fully showing the downward path, so i kinda tweaked it a bit so the path is more visible now..
As for the third point yes I have considered how to develop the gameplay further, I am still not sure about all its details yet, but it most likely wouldn't be just straight up stats boosting upgrades. I am considering it to be more like Charms from Hollow Knight, with a proper build of sorts that kinda stacks together. The details are still hazy but thats the general idea. Hopefully its fun.
Either way thanks for playing the Game.
I did work on a bit of those tweaks you mentioned so now atleast the game should be somewhat understandable in what it is trying to do. It has a more clear tutorial atleast but yes it does still end after the first day. The Endings of the game there are basically the route i see the story taking but nothing is set in stone yet. Glad you liked the Atmosphere, but yeaa the music does get repetitive after a while, I was kinda going for the Yume Nikki vibe but probably didn't reach that level of clarity yet
It has been a week but I did work on most of the things you did suggest so that took a while. But yes the game right now does basically end after the first day, I was mostly interested in getting the main gameplay loop done and see how people interact with it. This version is technically similar to that, but the main difference is that as you said it needed a more traditional tutorial, so did that, i am hoping it does make things make more sense.
The footstep particle thing was something I was supposed to fix ages ago but just slipped my mind. As for the lag issue, i had like a general idea of why that was happening in the previous version. It is kinda happening now as well not as sure why though but would figure it out soon enough. Forgot the Audio bit, will see what to do for that as well. But yeaaa thanks for playing the Game.
The game for the most part is plenty fun, and i reached about till the point where you recruit everyone but didn't do the any of the Mini bosses that come under the Neo Leader Squad. The Game also has the right amount of difficulty too, since i did fail a few times so couldnt completely steamroll the game without strategy. Also did like the hints in the names themselves of what the type of character it is, took me a while to realize it though. Another thing is that even though I haven't played the first game, calling back to it seems kinda fun, gives the world a feeling of more happening in it.
Two issues I can think of are that the Charlie Cutscenes, both of them did lag like a lot which i don't imagine is intentional. Other part being that while the gameplay is fun, after like the 9 times I did it, felt like kinda repetitive in its structure, maybe it does get better and the mini bosses and Final Boss has more variety I didn't reach there so not sure. Just the characters having different types of attack moves didn't feel like it meant enough of a variety in the actual gameplay.
Considering I didn't really die at all, i wouldn't say the game was particularly difficult but I did get close to it plenty times and was still about to weasel my way out of it mostly by using the plasma shield. One thing i do think could be an issue is that I didn't really feel like i needed to Move at all, since most of the damage seemed that it could be just be tanked for and then outhealed since enemies targeted different ships each time.
I completed like till the Third Level, so basically the boss fight one, and considering that I reached that far, means the game is pretty good, all things considered. There are a few things that still have to be taken care of though.
Mainly the lack of SFX is very much noticeable, so a lot of things that should have very high impact, do kinda lose a bit of there Juice, but i am sure that's something you are already working on. The other thing that felt a bit off was the Character Designs, i imagine what you are trying to do was something akin to how different worlds have different types of people in it so they feel and look different, but that doesn't as much work in this, especially the Dronghur Leader he when compared to the Main Characters feel a bit too jarring.
Also the Main UI screen probably could do with a bit of Rework in style, especially considering I do like the style its in the Play Menu, so just anything that doesn't feel like the default font options of Godot.
The Gameplay itself I am not sure I have much to critique for since I don't play enough of these types of Games, but all the cards and the way they work feels like a unique enough compared to the other deck builder games i have tried before, and it all works in the Setting. Also while the first cutscene did feel a bit goofy, the second one was pretty cool, even though stylistically it felt way different then anything else in the game.
So about the Breakneck , it mostly came down the UI reminding me of something like the WWE Career mode option, but I did actually start with Breakneck only, issue was that I just lost to the first enemy twice, basically by going outside the Ring myself, mostly because the controls were new to me, and probably also because of the part where I skipped a lot of the Tutorial Text.
And after that I just went to the Brawl and that felt way more Streamlined to actually play the game, so did that only until I could beat the AI in hard. I did fill the form, so now do realise the part where Breakneck is supposed to be more of a Roguelite which does actually sound pretty fun at least compared to the Career path i was initially considering.
I do love the idea of a Beyblade game, and the gameplay was basically everything I imagined it to be so thats great. I am still not entirely sure if I understood most of anything about the Game, but I imagine it similar to a scenario of normal fighting games where any casual player would get immediately destroyed when playing online, atleast based on the amount of stuff that was on the Tutorial. Probably still not the best idea to have so much stuff right at the start though, it feels like a situation where you need a basic tutorial and an advance one separately, since I did basically start skipping over text when i realised how much of it there was.
I did figure out that Reina is probably the best character, since even without knowing anything I was actually able to beat the AI at hard difficulty in both the 1 vs 1, and free for all, so plenty satisfied with the progress made. Didn't actually do the Breakneck though seemed like it would take too long.
The Game does do mostly everything right, the one thing that did feel kinda off was how big the Menu Buttons got when they were hovered on but that's just a minor nitpick.
I played for like 30 min and reached like Floor 46, the core game loop is plenty strong, the only issue I did have was that I felt the game was progressing pretty slowly, considering the amount of Floors I had went through. And then I realised I was Stupid.
It took me till Floor 36 to realise that the base pickaxe could be Upgraded and that only happened when I was trying to get the Stronger Pickaxe which needed the base one to be Max. I have no idea how I missed that, but would definitely helped the feeling of slowness I guess. But also it does mean that not much options exist to feel like there is progress being made. To be fair, I imagine more things would come up later as well, but maybe some of it could come sooner. Just a thought that one.
Other than that the Game feels pretty nice overall, and all the quality of life features are great too, wouldn't have played the 30 min if it didn't have the Hover option. The Game also has all the Juice options an incremental game like this would need so that's all good too.
Also I read this being a thing related to Metal Poisoning and so maybe then you should go even deeper into the surrealist nature of it, that would also give the Game that unique identity it needs. Maybe that does happen later on already so don't know about that.
The Audio might have been due to the type of file you were using since Godot does behave a lot differently between the ogg and wav files, not entirely sure about that. As for the design, Also I think for the most part you did pretty good design wise, the game was a bit challenging but never unfair and getting good is the part which is most fun in these type of games so its all fine. it is nice to create something you would like yourself.
I am not sure if it was because i bugged something out or not but just the same characters kept coming back asking for the same thing again and again, but if it was intentional then I do think a vaguely progressive storyline is a much better fit for this type of game. Also seeing how some characters do mention coins that was probably a skipped mechanic of the game but that would help a lot too on the gameplay feel and decision making.
Took me a while but I did actually manage to finish the game. There were a few bugs like the audio stopping midway and stuff which was fine since nothing game breaking. I do love the texts you added in between which added its own little charm to it. The Platforming and Character control itself was quite nice too but considering how paced everything usually could be, just the waiting period for stuff to come back was a bit much/ Not sure if that was just a me issue though.




