I reached like the 9th in Abyss and got stuck, like couldn't find the way further. I would assume I have to go through this hole but maybe the collision isn't set as right because I sure couldn't do it no matter how much I tried. But I do know its possible since a Centipede did do it, and I don't think there was any other paths since I did circle around quite a number of times.
As for the game itself, its great. The movement is great, the sonar is great and the enemy design all seems great. The gameplay itself does maybe need to be a bit more punishing just considering the fact that I never really died in the game but I did get close sometimes but was able to full heal the next time anyhow. The game was able to scare me a few times though whenever something would fall from the ceiling that was nice. The Spiders, I think as enemy should probably be a bit more threatening considering I think they are the only ones I never really took damage too, maybe the hunter one could have a bit more of a quicker shot and the whip one would have more of a range.
In a lot of cases, when I am just at the middle of the caves I think I am a bit too safe, but also those are times when something falling from the sky is most terrifying so maybe there is a balance that's needed.
The balance would also maybe make the pebbles more useful since even though I did always collect them I don't think I ever really needed them much except maybe the boss fights but even them it didn't seem like they could do much. Also atleast in the second Centipede Mother fight I could just cheese it by going near the resonance stone and it just standing there, not sure if that's by design could work nicely for some people who do figure it out maybe.
The issue that came up most in regards to the game was essentially that as the Map got bigger the fireflies got harder to find and I just spent a lot of time looping around with no way forward. In the beginning atleast, I got all of them but by the time I reached the Abyss finding them all was too much work. An arrow might be too much but maybe there would be some structure that could atleast point in the general direction of the fly when hit by the sonar could be nice.
Another important thing would be the abilities, I am not as sure about how much of a gameplay difference they made the full health one was basically the one i chose most. I got the wall sense one like near the end, didn't feel like it did much but I was stuck so maybe that different. The attracting fly one maybe worked usefully once or twice when there were too many enemies clogged up at one place which I didn't wanna go through, but maybe the radius could be increased a bit more for that. The enemy linger one definitely was way more harmful then it was useful since the enemies would move on and I would still be thinking they were just there for a bit longer then I should have. I can't remember any more of them but I suppose they do minor improvements in quality of life bits so its probably working as intended.
I think I covered just about everything, so yeaa, its a fun game. You are doing great. Good luck doing more great things.
Viewing post in ECHO jam comments
Thank you for such a thorough playtest, this is exactly the kind of feedback that shapes the beta.
About getting stuck in Abyss 9: I checked hundreds of generated caves and the way to the exit is always wide enough for the bat. I'm fairly sure the "hole" was the exit crack itself, which stays sealed until you've eaten enough fireflies, and the game never told you that. Now it does: fly under a closed crack and it says how many fireflies are still missing.
I also took your idea about finding fireflies. A full-strength cry now makes the nearest fireflies you still need glint at the edge of the screen for a couple of seconds, pointing the way. It's live now if you want to try it.
Your other notes are on my list for the next updates: spiders and the hunter being too easy to avoid, pebbles feeling unnecessary, the Centipede Mother standing still near the resonance stone, and the "enemy linger" gift doing more harm than good. Thanks again, and good luck with Nezarot!