Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines
(1 edit)

Maybe I should get more people be mentally exhausted before making them play the game because all of this is plenty useful. Glad you like the style and vibes of the game. I will see how I can improve upon each of your points.
For the tree tutorial and the whole tree in general, I suppose it would make more sense to go forward as the stage of concern for the tree increases where the music would get more tense the longer you have been planting which would probably work better then being that tense throughout.
I would like you to explain the counterintuitive part more though whenever you give the game another shot. The tree gameplay is something I am very curious about because as it stands I am not really sure how good it actually at a base level. I have started to add on a bit onto it, but probably best to secure the base first, so any thoughts you have about it would help out a lot.
For some bits I guess you did miss some dialogues like in regards to the Fruits being gone but yeaa the Seed one isn't as directly acknowledged. Will make changes to make some more of the UI things clear too, hopefully it would make more sense then.
Either way thank you for giving the game a shot even once.

I tried it from my phone since I don't have access to my laptop right now. I went through the tutorial section involving the tree, but there are no controls available after that, so I can't provide any feedback yet

(2 edits)

Hi! I finally found some time to give the game another try, this time on my computer.

First of all, please keep in mind that these are just my subjective impressions.

A few things I noticed:

  • Selecting seeds: Changing the selected seed doesn't give much visual feedback. Although I later noticed that the currently selected seed is displayed in the bottom-left corner.
  • Time indicator: The icon in the top-right corner didn't immediately look like a time indicator to me. At first, I thought it was some kind of coin.
  • Seed placement: I'm wondering if it's really necessary to make the player figure out which seed fits into which slot. Does this add something meaningful to the gameplay?
  • Harvesting fruit: Collecting fruit doesn't provide much feedback either. For example, some visual response on the slot itself, along with an indication in the inventory showing what was just collected, would make the action feel clearer.
  • Black infection: The black infection keeps growing, but there doesn't seem to be anything you can do about it until metastases appear. In the introductory tutorial, I think we managed to completely remove the infection, so this confused me a little. Although I might be remembering that incorrectly.
  • Tree complexity: Is it really necessary to introduce a three-section tree right at the beginning, before the player has had enough time to understand the basic mechanics?
  • Unclear icons: I've either forgotten or never fully understood what the hat and webcam-like icons mean in the area with the tree navigation arrow and the button for skipping a day.
  • Growth stages: It's not visually clear to me whether a fruit is currently at a stage where I need to interact with it or whether I should simply let time pass.

But the biggest issue for me is understanding what I'm supposed to do at any given moment.

Should I place a seed somewhere (and first figure out which one fits)? Should I fight the infection? Should I boost the plant? Or should I just skip time and wait?

Individually, I understand how most of these mechanics work. But when they're all presented together, I often feel lost and unsure what the game actually expects me to do next.

I think that's the main source of confusion for me. It's not necessarily that the mechanics themselves are too complicated, but rather that the game doesn't always communicate clearly what the player should be focusing on at a particular moment.

----

And I finally figured out what your game's atmosphere reminds me of!

I once watched a very niche film called White Plastic Sky (Müanyag égbolt), and your game gives me a very similar feeling. That same mysterious, unsettling atmosphere, and even some similarities in the themes.

That's the vibe I've been getting from your game!

---

Hopefully, these observations will be useful!

Thanks a lot, all this information is very much helpful and I will try to figure out how I can use this to make the game better. For some of the things you have mentioned I can think of very clear solutions, so for the selecting seeds and harvesting fruits bit just needs some visual indication for that and it would be enough. The Black Infection bit is also something that I could kinda make more visually clear of what is removable and what not, but as for the Tutorial as it states that was just the simulated version of the Nezarot and not the actual thing. 

As for the Seed placement bit, its not like the player has to figure out which seed is for what everytime since the seeds are divided in a manner that indicates which seedbed they belong to. Atleast that was the idea behind it, that players would realize it after the first day or two, originally the game didn't have this but I just added this into the loop for a bit more complexity in how you approach the Tree.
I am curious in regards to the Growth Stages since I was hoping that the progress bar that was besides it was a clear enough indicator to the fact that it was now in a different stage. 

Now focusing onto your final point of what the player should be doing at any given moment, I think it just comes down to what they feel is right at the moment so it could be any of the things you mentioned. The only two considerations for it would be that the Tree isn't fully consumed and that you reach your target and however you do that is fine. Atleast that's my idea for what it should be.

The White Plastic Sky bit is something that is surprisingly similar to the themes and vibes I am going for. I had never heard of it before but I did see the trailer just now and it looks quite interesting, I will look more into it and see where it goes could help a bit in making my own world.
My bad if I come off a bit aggressive when you are only trying to help, truly didn't mean to do that. Your observations have really been helpful and I will see how I can make the game better based on everything you have said.