This game definitely blew away all my expectations based on the description you gave me but this is some really great work. On a gameplay level, I am sure you have a bit more work to do but in terms of the atmosphere of the game, you have really nailed the vibe even with the placeholder assets you are using. I did the full tutorial, and two runs of the Manor one which went on the standard manor and the other which went through the Gardens. On a technical level, I don't think I learnt much about the actual Manor, but it hits the uncanny fantastical vibes that I am a really big fan of.
In terms of actual mechanics, I do like the choose your own adventure style dice roles where a lot of things don't really go your way but you can risk it for knowing more about the World. I would like you to add some choices that unlike the dice roles do guarantee your choice but would just affect the stats directly like how it works in case of Stamina. Maybe it does work like that in some other places, but stamina was the only place I actually noticed this. But considering failing these checks usually isn't a run ended that's not as bad and more like you just get sucked deeper into a different rabbit hole.
The combat mechanics on the other hand may need a bit more agency from the player. For the most part I didn't really think I needed to change the player from the Normal Style since it was balanced enough compared to the Aggressive one where the only reason you would do that is if the enemy was just slightly above your usual damage range. Not sure why you would use the Defense builds at all, but there are more charms and benefits that prop up later on which from the looks of things is highly likely, I do kinda like the idea of just dying because you are just too weak in front of otherwordly horrors though. In the garden, I ran away from the Crow Knight, running away usually did seem like the smarter option in a lot of fights. And then just facing a statue of otherwordly horrors that one shot me anyhow. That was great.
I do think the Tutorial prologue isn't nearly as interesting but that's probably because it is still in very normalish world that kinda follows the rules, and you still have to establish the baseline setting.Not really sure how you could possibly balance both of those together, but probably your best bet would just be that the player just perseveres through till the game actually gets interesting.
Two more things, probably shouldn't call going back to the settings as Open the Book, thats just confusing and I sure didn't realize that for a while. Other thing was that I found a typo on the Two Corridors, Neither Right where it should say "can't help but". I am sure you can figure out where that is.
That's about all my thoughts on the game, I hope you are able to get an actual artist for the art of the game because with that I am sure you could make this really big. Good luck in making more of this.
Hi pal, thanks for leaving your comment, I'll address your points:
- for what concerns events and choices, the idea is that you can test your vital resources, help your odds by boosting the success rate with focus (spending determination), or get a granted success via stamina. In some rare cases you can directly spend determintaion.
the tension should play as follows: do I want to test resources aiming for a reward, do I prefer an easy win (via stamina) that will cost me less tactical options while fighting, or do I just leave the things be and go for the next event?
- You are right that in the current state there is little reason to shift from normal stance, but as fights get more difficult and dice pool grow, stances become,together with your equipment, the way for you to access different dice pools.
Not sure if it was clear that stance + equipment = your attack / defense die. Like if the enemy is going for a big hit, your best bet would be to go all-in with defense with defensive stance + defend as core action to double your DEF dice.
On top of that, combat plays out deterministically, with enemies reacting to various conditions that are either the player state/health bar, the round of the fight, what was your last move (e.g. if you switched stances, or if you stayed still for too long); as they get more complicated, leveraging the systems becomes a necessity. You can steamroll the entry hall easily, but you'll have a hard time surviving the Gardens if you don't use what the combat system has to offer.
Thanks for your words, I'll be studying what options I have :)