Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

Constructive feedback Sticky

A topic by DarkThreadStudio created 17 days ago Views: 794 Replies: 27
Viewing posts 1 to 8
Developer (1 edit)

Kera's story is very much still a work in progress. The goal is simply to improve and make the story better in every way possible over time. For this - we need useful and continuous feedback from those willing to provide it. Want to point out the best part of the story? Want to point out some parts that didn't quite land? A scene that doesn't quite land right? An issue with pacing or otherwise? Feel free to share your thoughts. Alternatively, if you do not wish to post on Itch - you can write Darkthreadstudio@outlook.com


QUESTION: How long on average is it taking folks to finish the story?

(1 edit) (+3)

Reposting the gist of my initial thoughts, I'm torn between whether Kera eats the player too soon or too late. Her stalker behavior leads me to think there should be an avenue where you ruin her fun enough that she eats you sooner, and her stalker behavior leads me to think she'd want to drag things out for longer than one scene on the other occasions where you don't annoy her into ending the game she's playing with you early.

Developer(+2)

This is a good idea and could be wickedly fun. Potential for introducing another daytime scene tension builder, with more character exposition and a potential.. early conclusion.. It's quite simple to add in earlier conversation options that may irritate her. This is good feedback. thanks.

(1 edit) (+4)

i feel that the game is a little short, i feel that the player could have chosen scenarios to avoid kera from eating player to soon, and the longer he is alive the more insatiable she becomes. I do like the game, so please dont get the wrong idea

Developer(+1)

Not at all. The fact that you feel its short suggests it is successful in engaging you. If it feels too short it's because it is. I think there's potential for another scene between Dinner and Twilight. This is something I'll think about how it will work.

(+2)

Great game, I really enjoyed the writing and was surprised how much character Kera has. I'm a sucker for a dominant pred, so this is 100% up my alley! I do hope there will be at least one more full day added before the final sequence. Any plans to include any other kinks besides vore?

Developer

Kind feedback, thank you! There is a fine line between bad and good insanity, and it's hard to know where it lands until its out there, and now more work begins. Yeah, i understand a not insignificant number of folks are going to be hoping for different kinks - so in lore anyway, If Newcomer wants it that way, Kera would be happy to oblige him with some.. fairly realistic looking accessories. IF she liked him enough. In terms of a full extra day - The amount of work is staggering and I'd never get it finished. But the good news is - I'm already working on one long additional outing that I think people will like before sunset. If you like Kera's character - you've seen about 10% of it. She's revealing very little in the first story.

(+1)

Após uma sessão particularmente longa de newgames e MUITOS loads, cheguei a conclusão que adorei esse jogo, é simples, mas bem executado, ainda mais quanto a construção de personagem. Kera é definitivamente uma garota má, que simplesmente mergulhou de cabeça em sua propria obcessão e fome, como ela mesma disse, nós não somos o primeiro, mas somos, em comparação, o melhor aperitivo que ela ja provou.

As músicas especias são incríveis, a letra é certeira no contexto da história, algum dia espero poder ter essas musicas para minha playlist pessoal.

Aguardo ansiosamente por futuras atualizações, gostaria de ver mais dessa história, talvez um segundo dia onde possamos investigar mais a fundo a mente de Kera e, com muita sorte, prolongar nossa estadia nesse mundo antes dele se reduzir ao estômago dela, mouthplay talvez? Quem sabe? Uma falsa esperança de fugir dela só para prolongar um pouquinho nossa existencia? Eu não sei.

Developer (2 edits) (+1)

Olá! Estou usando o Google Tradutor para te responder,

Muito obrigado do fundo do coração por dedicar um tempo para escrever isso — significa que a escrita está funcionando, e não havia nenhuma certeza de que funcionaria, então isso é ótimo.

A trilha sonora é algo de que me orgulho — e na versão .81 você agora tem um jukebox que pode usar no final da história. Os apoiadores definitivamente vão receber um pacote completo em .mp3 incluído mais tarde.

A má notícia é que não vejo nenhuma maneira do Novato (Newcomer) sobreviver à noite — e a história e os scripts de gatilho já estão super configurados para que esses eventos aconteçam. A boa notícia é que estou trabalhando para deixar o dia mais longo, e também posso te garantir que este é apenas o Capítulo I. A história não acabou... a história de origem da Kera vai se aprofundar com o tempo.

É interessante você mencionar 'prolongar a existência com uma falsa esperança...' 😉

(+1)

Alright, I do really like the game and concept, but I have a few narrative issues and one thing that hits a major pet peeve of mine.

1. The player character is kind of... forced to be an idiot to a degree that gets very frustrating very fast. Even discounting for genre savviness from me the player, it becomes excessively clear something's off super early and unless you do some arbitrary sleuthing during the story, you'll just... ignore all the obvious red flags. This is really frustrating to me as a player and kind of throws a major wrench in the narrative's enjoyability. 

2. In the current "good" (ish) ending when you get to actually have a conversation with Kera at the end... it actually sort of makes her less enjoyable of a character in my opinion, and not just because of her stalker-like behavior. She claims she never lied, but there are multiple times where she actively did and you're not allowed to bring them up (also the flimsy excuses for her saying you just "inferred" she lied are just that, flimsy excuses and the fact the player character just lets them slide is another point that frustrates me with him being an idiot again). She has that extreme holier than thou attitude and comes across more like preachy pro-vegan propaganda than a predator when you get to the point that you both eat meat (which is a shit point for her anyway and hurts her argument more than helps it) and so on, honestly that whole conversation just retroactively ruins her whole character up to that point and needs a LOT of work, or if I was writing, I would make it so that her arguments are actually fairly easy for the player character to discredit and throw her off because well... they ARE easy to debunk and discredit, her argument is terrible.

3.
The resist minigame. It's very frustrating that succeeding it repeatedly just gives you an unwinnable scenario and sort of ruins any enjoyment of the scene. I've said this to multiple people in the past but you're actually hurting the scene by adding something like that. Why bother having such an annoying minigame if no matter what you get treated the same in the end? Either have a completely different outcome if the player succeeds on the three possible ones or don't have it in at all, the impossible one comes across as a massive middle finger to the player for no reason. 

Developer

Thanks for taking the time Renamon. I can work with this.

1. You're absolutely right. Newcomer is an idiot. I thought about trying to make the end a total blindside, but because every person that's downloaded it has seen the vore tags and the warnings there was no way a total surprise was going to be pulled off. Instead It has to be a bit more tongue in cheek.

I think you're talking about finding enough clues in the apartment for newcomer to decide not to go to sleep, which could be frustrating to go back and find. Do you think people should be able to progress to the better endings without looking around the apartment?

2.

Lies If there's a time when she outright lied that I've forgotten, please point it out to me. I may have made a mistake.

Vegan Perhaps I haven't made that segment clear enough.. Kera doesn't care if you're vegan or not. Right now you get exactly zero points with her by claiming to be.  From her perspective - She's more irritated by Newcomer 'hunting' via supermarket and being squeamish about the reality of it. You're probably right. I might need to sharpen the point here.


3. Minigames - Good news here. Those minigames will count for something soon. The true ending is something I'll be actively working on once i've finished extending the day length for .85


Thanks for your time.

(10 edits)

For the question in point 1: ...Yeah? Like, honestly her actions just from you acting along should be a massive red flag if he stops and thinks about it. Hell, the fact he doesn't immediately realize he should just bounce the moment he looks around the apartment is kind of inexcusable from a narrative standpoint if you do it while Kera's in the tub. There's absolutely no narrative reason why he shouldn't put 2 and 2 together right then and there rather than in bed later.

For the lies, every time she intentionally acts coy or leads you into believing something, that is a lie. It's a lie by omission, and her claiming it wasn't a lie at all is also a lie. There is no deception without some form of lying, so her trying to say she never lied isn't something you can fix as a writer, it's just her automatically lying due to the nature of the story. Either she lied, or she could never have deceived you to begin with. There is no third option there for her to be like "I never TECHNICALLY lied" without it being such a huge flaw in her reasoning you could drive a truck through it.

EDIT: Just realized there really is a specific lie you should be able to point out that can't be discounted due to the fact you have to find out that the message to get you to come was fabricated just to reach that conversation to begin with. She lied by telling you (using your friend's phone) that they needed a dogsitter. The entire plot revolves around her having lied to you BEFORE you ever met her. 

For the vegan section, I'm not saying anything about claiming Newcomer is a vegan or that, I'm saying her statements at that point sound like the same kind of anti-meat eating rhetoric you get out of vegans. It sounds like she's being incredibly preachy in a "I'm 14 and this is deep" level of understanding, or in other words despite the game trying to present her as way smarter than she's letting on, she actually comes across as childish and like she barely understands anything she's talking about.

I legitimately don't know how you could fully fix this without it requiring you to completely rewrite the scene, but I feel like a good start would be a way to actually break Kera by talking, with her losing her stride by you deconstructing her (again) frankly ridiculous points. The crux of the problem is that Kera's entire speech, her argument for the way she is, in that final section is just... bad. She comes across more like she's projecting some edgy OC than anything she actually thinks, and the fact you just have to go along with it no matter what dialogue you pick isn't very satisfying.

(+2)(-1)

I believe Kera's point is that this is just the natural way of things for monsters and men: monsters eat men, and it's something they must do by their nature. I believe that forms the crux of her own "morality" on the subject, which is probably why the Vegan point bothers her, because it runs counter to her own thinking about what she does, and what she argues she must do.

That... doesn't really help any, nor does it address the crux of the issue at all.

(+2)(-1)

Then what is the crux of the issue? As far as I can tell, the point of the Vegan thing is that Kera's trying to rationalize doing something she only kind of wants to resist, but doesn't actually in the end, because it's hard. She seems to be trying to paint Newcomer into the same corner. I'm not seeing the "I'm 14 and this is deep" aspect.

(4 edits) (-2)

It's not JUST that part (like I said in the post you initially replied to actually), that's just a point that stands out. Her whole argument for the entire bedroom section is flimsy and sounds more like she's trying to convince herself than she actually believes anything she says. But even then, the dialogue options you have are frustratingly bad when you get to reply. I immediately thought of MULTIPLE major flaws in all of her points, and the fact that even the good arguments you get just result in the main character horribly fumbling them is cringeworthy at best. 

Also for the "I'm 14 and this is deep" bit, how about her entire spiel about "I am that mirror" when she gets into that part? It legit threw me out of the scene because it doesn't fit at all and really does just sound like a teenager's first edgy OC. Which is really rather a shame because like I said, up til that scene I really liked the character. It's a fun concept and I love to see it, but as I put it earlier, that conversation retroactively ruins everything that made her interesting.

And uh, no offense meant, but I'd really rather talk with the dev than with you. It's not really constructive feedback if we turn this into a petty back and forth disagreement like this.

Developer (1 edit)

Thanks - I don't see that aspect either, but invariably some people will. If one person points out an argument doesn't make sense, another hundred are thinking it quietly. The difficulty is in getting the balance right.

It's challenging because I know Kera's backstory, and what she likes and dislikes in humanity, and what her internal conflict is about. Unfortunately - I can't reveal any of that now. We have to look at it from Newcomers perspective just having met her. However, in the dialogue she does drop some pretty strong hints what she's trying to assess in Newcomer.

(1 edit) (+1)

I had a thought just now, but why not instead of making it a requirement to find the clues in the apartment just to reach the bedroom conversation, why not instead have them let you derail Kera's argument? The clues honestly work better as massive holes in her argument than as reasons for the player character to be able to avoid drifting off to sleep with how many red flags she gives to begin with.

The phone is proof positive she lied to you from the start, and isn't something she can write off as not technically a lie. The fact she forgot to get rid of things out in the open like the friend's wallet shows that she isn't some amazing perfect predator like she pretends because she couldn't even manage to hide obvious evidence of her misdoings. The bowl in the kitchen and much of her actions leading up to the conversation show that her urge isn't so much irresistible as much as it's hard to believe she's ever actually TRIED to resist it.

Developer(+1)

Now there's the beginnings of an idea, thank you. 

Finding those items, or even potentially additional evidence to push back against her and interrupt her roll, is something I honestly hadn't thought of until now. When Kera gets on a dark monologue it is important to interrupt her before it escalates.

Finding something throughout the course of the game that allows you to do so is a really neat idea.


Just with regards to the phone - She does already openly admit to that, the line is:

K "Aside from the obvious deception of using your friends phone to lure you here.."

K "-I haven't directly lied to you since we met.. It's not my style.."

Kera lies when she wants to, but has more fun stringing humans along. We could potentially call her out for it - in direct and accurate fashion.. And then what? She doesn't care. She knows she's a manipulator. So what would the outcome be from throwing it in her face?


So, you're quite adamant about this, It seems like you want to beat her in an argument, which is interesting for a couple of reasons.

You've made it clear that her angle that can broadly be described as

"You eat meat, I eat you, it's fair. Don't claim moral highground"

that its an argument you clearly want to take down. Please feel free to do so, So i can understand where you're really coming from.

(2 edits) (+1)

Well for a start, I would like to point out that I'm not saying "beating her" in the argument should automatically change your overall fate (assuming that my reading of her is correct and it would be wildly out of character for her to just spare someone for talking her down). It'd be more that doing so would get Kera to actually look at you differently than just any other prey. You're making her think about it, and that's unusual.

As for how to beat the "You eat meat, I eat you" argument, a big problem with it is her framing of it. She tries to equate you eating chicken (which was raised for the sole sake of being eventually eaten, and the majority of domestic chickens and cows would be entirely incapable of living without human intervention in the first place) to her eating you alive. And she wants to eat you in a way that she actively makes things worse and more stressful for her prey, in contrast to how humans generally try to avoid making livestock unnecessarily suffer. 

Even if her argument is that she doesn't care about that aspect, it makes her entire argument unfairly biased in her own favor and hypocritical rather than accurate. On top of that, she also tries to frame it as a specific punishment towards humans, when the implications are pretty clear that she doesn't only eat humans when she hunts, so trying to go into this dark monologue about how she's a balancing factor comes across as it stands as extremely hollow. Like I said multiple times, it sounds more like she's projecting some edgy OC over herself than saying anything she actually believes.


On the topic of her not caring about the lying and such, that explanation that she doesn't care feels hollow to me from a writing standpoint. I do a lot of writing myself, and if I had a character who didn't care about lying and being manipulative, I wouldn't have them actively make a point of pride about not lying. If she doesn't care, why does she argue she never lied? That simply doesn't track. She clearly does care about being deceptive if she's going to defend her action, so her lies, direct and indirect, getting pointed out should affect her. Otherwise she should just brush the "you've lied to me" comment off with something like "Yes, your point?" rather than trying so hard to claim she never lied (which isn't true).

Also other cases she directly lied: She said while staying here she was fed MULTIPLE gourmet items (no, the "Maaaaaaaybe" response to Newcomer's incredulous question does not make it not a lie. That's still a lie, she knows exactly what she's getting Newcomer to think and it's obviously meant as a positive answer. This isn't a debatable case of "well it's only a yes from Newcomer's perspective" it's a yes from EVERY perspective.), she claims she has no idea why the dog in the park ran away after she clearly scared it herself, and there's even the argument that she lied when she referred to Newcomer multiple times as a "New Friend" as she clearly never had friendly intentions to begin with.

(Edit: On rereading this I see it came across as SIGNIFICANTLY more harsh than intended. Sorry about that, I really do like your work and am just kind of passionate about wanting to help improve it.)

Developer(+1)

Not to worry. It was clear to me from the get-go that you got drawn into the story enough to care about it. You're just happen to be what would be considered, quite blunt.

Your points have merit, Some useful insight in there thanks.. I've already made some minor changes to the end sequence for .85, but will return to the final sequence in earnest for the next patch. I'll keep your thoughts in mind. You've already shifted .85 slightly.

Well then, I look forward to seeing what you do!

(+2)

This game caught me by surprise. I was relatively expecting kind of a standard silly-feel vore scenario, where we're like into it or our relationship with Kera is relatively normal plus the vore as a kink. However fully playing through it, this game blew my mind with realism and actual terror (that damn door opening at night). The detail in which you made a soft vore scenario along with a real world idea of predators and prey mixed into one was genius. The whole feeling of severity that stuck around the entire game felt very real and made the end game all the more terrifying while experiencing it. While immersed in the game I was hoping at the end that Kera might spare us and keep us around as a boyfriend and a potential "treat", but we know what happened. Never the less, this was great to play and I love how you made the game actually take itself seriously rather than the common "silly-feel" that a lot of vore games end up as. You have my max rating for this game and I can not wait to see how you expand this. Also a side note, that final song with lyrics was straight fire!

I don't have much else to add except maybe a suggestion for the game's further development. I don't know what you're planning, but if the game's story continues after that first night I have an idea that; depending on our choices and responses to Kera throughout the first day, she will choose not to eat us that night and tease to "keep us around". Further upon that, I imagine if she does keep us around she makes us find other humans for her to eat instead of us, along with plenty of love making. Basically she keeps us hostage in order for us to bring her other prey, otherwise she eats us. Further towards an end game idea, if we play her game long enough and make the correct choices along the way, she basically falls in love with us and no longer wants to eat us (but still will if we make a bad choice early on) and so she gives us the choice to leave her for our own sake, or we stay with her as her mate, or of course we let her eat us anyway (gotta have that willing vore ending). This is my main idea as a suggestion. Either way I look forward to seeing this game expand. Thank you for making it and good luck on it's development!

Developer (2 edits) (+1)

Wow. Appreciate it dude. Let me think on this for a bit.

To your thoughts on Newcomer and Kera, right now I need to keep the true ending of this chapter a secret. But I can point out the obvious, that right at the end there, there's an alternate scene greyed out and another menu item at the end for a post credits scene. It is planned to be a long one.

Regarding the 'Mans best friend' track, that was the single most fucked up feverdream idea I've ever had. I don't know where it came from, but I gave an idea and generated a terrible first draft of lyrics on some website, and it was shit, so I left it for a while. One day I was sitting in a utility cupboard somewhere instead of working, and messed with the lyrics myself until there was nothing of the original left. As soon as I thought of the bad girl line, I realized it was going to fuck with peoples heads. It is awful. That's the idea.

That track started it all. It set the vibe and the feel of her personality, and the story was built around it, not the other way around.

Anyway. .85 is on the way, but its slow going. I've put about 30 hours into it already this week. I'm quite confident people are going to love it.  

I did notice that greyed out choice (after another playthrough, lol) and I look forward to seeing how that goes.

I've never messed around with AI music myself so I can't say I know how easy or hard it is to make something sound good (though I have seen how dumb the AI's can be on their own). But whatever you did to fine tune it, I applaud you for that and I'm really glad it worked out. I'm a sucker for dark themes and romance so this song hit me in the heart and I honestly love it.

No sweat brother. I'll definitely be keeping my eye out for the next update!

(1 edit) (+1)

1. I hope you consider setting up a Discord server. Kera has the potential to be one of the best vore VNs around, so you may soon find yourself neck-deep in fans who want a better way to communicate with you than Itch or email can provide. Just a thought.

 2. The vorarephile furry-minded lens: Newcomer seems like a fairly normal, if not stupid, human specimen. Though he's dumb, I still can't shake the inconsistency in his reactions, which fluctuate between a normal person and a somewhat furry brain. I think Treats' reactions would resonate better if viewed through a vorephile, furry-minded lens, especially given that both the dev and the target audience are part of it. I think that I would personally be more open to making bad decisions and ignoring glaring warning signs if I found myself in front of a non-pretend in-the-flesh furry hottie. Treats reactions could then be viewed as more horny stupid than just stupid. Well, a little at least. 

3. Kera's vorarephile boyfriend? I think a couple of options here stand out if you like this idea. 3.1 is that Kera lured in a treat but ended up with a type of weirdo that she has never encountered before.  A furry vorarephile.  The fact that she is a monster fox girl who eats peeps on the regular makes her extra appealing to him.  Kad she HAS to eat someone, I hear you say? Ooo, and he smells so good that she can't stand it? Well, the simple fix for that, my friend, is for her to go out and grab some fast food(Hehe you know what I mean). When you have food in ya, your hunger cravings go way down.  Now, Treat has a foxy, man-eating girlfriend, and Kera has a boyfriend (for the first time?).

3.2 The other option is that Kera already has a furry-brained vorarephile boyfriend. You know that friend that we presume that Kera has eaten? What if that, in fact, was her boyfriend and he really was away on a business trip? He comes back shortly after Kera had her treat, and they enjoy some alone time together. Perhaps even while treat is still awake? Sounds nice to me. I personally like the contrast of Kera having a prey human boyfriend while she noms her way through society to be...enjoyable. 

Anyway, I really like your VN thus far and hope that you keep up the good work. Cheers.

Developer(+1)

This is a pretty big compliment. Thank you, sincerely.

* With regards to setting up discord or a better platform, I thought about it, and hopefully we get there in terms of popularity, obviously I'm getting some pretty kind feedback, Kera is approaching 150 followers, which is nice for 3 weeks,  but overall the situation appears to be ~3300 downloads and so far < 20 people willing to rate or give feedback. if setting up a discord, it has to be like, well, is it successful enough to warrant that (success meaning is anybody willing to pay 4-5 bucks for the finished story when its ready) and also consider the privacy and moderation requirements.. I don't know. I have thought though, that I do want to encourage people to fan theorize about Kera, and i've also thought a Kerabot might be a fun idea to stir fans up. Time will tell.

* You're probably right that Newcomer has some inconsistencies in his character, it could certainly probably use a going over and some tweaks where needed, if there are any of his responses that really break immersion please let me know, but i'll also just give some context here on who he has to be -

This story is so absurd that Newcomer has to be as well, suspending the readers disbelief relies on a lot of cheap tricks - the ominous soundtrack (exploration.mp3 does so much heavy lifting it's not funny), Kera's insane Sass, the back and forth banter, the background danger, the dry humor. Because he is being dragged through all these absurd situations it is challenging to nail down a firm "Newcomer would do this" mindset because he is genuinely losing his mind. I think of him more in the "I saw Lola bunny and now I'm confused" camp.

In his defense though - He's dumb because he has to be, but the player can make him say smart things on occasion. The other thing that should be obvious by now - the thing a smart person would have done is run. If it's not clear by now, with the new patch - the poor guy was fucked from the moment she caught his scent in the apartment, she'll find him. So doing the smart thing results in him being dead too.

Your points 3, 3.1, & 3.2 are .. Pushing on plot points that I can't reveal yet.. Those earlier story threads you mentioned are not abandoned and forgotten about, they will return later for a twist. I can tell you that the machinery behind Kera's behavior is perhaps even darker and more fucked up than you've alluded to.

Thanks for your time Kadarth.

(3 edits)

No, thank you for making your little hobby passion project available to the community.  I've dipped my pinky toe into the AI art world and know just how maddening it can be to get two pictures to even somewhat resemble each other, let alone the number you've gotten with Kera. My hat is off to you.  Writing and grammar seem fine to me, but I'm no wordsmith. No real bugs I've come across, which is saying something good about the dev's coding skills.  Kera's design, in both artwork and personality, is delightful in every aspect. I especially love the little innuendo that she is more or less forced to be a man-eater, not saying that she wouldn't do it anyway, but that her body gives her a ticking clock for a snackrifice to be made. I just love it.  Unless I'm wrong and am projecting.... I also like the overall vibe of newcomer and the artwork style you chose. Very cute.

Points 3-3.2 were not meant as questions nor suggestions, just some sick vorarephile musings. Sorry about the confusion there. 

Now, as for newcomers' state of mind, let's just first say that this is just my opinion on the subject.  Everyone is a critic, as they say.  That being said, I found most of his reactions to Kera throughout the front half of the story thus far to be... unbelievable...for a non-furry-minded person, regardless of how smart he is or not, or how confused he is.  I know there are parts of the story that suggest he has a slightly furry mindset later on, but even then it doesn't feel like enough to justify where his mind goes.  I feel like even the smartest people in the furry community would fall into the honey trap of "holy cow, a real-life furry hottie!? SCORE! Nothing else matters! No other thoughts necessary. Brain, what do you mean by 'red flags'?" Can't you see how lucky I am? I'm turning you off now. Goodbye."   I just think that if Newcomer were given this explanation that he is even somewhat a furry, that it would make any/and all of the "inconsistencies" align with his choices. I think it would also resonate better with the target audience, since most of us are presumably furries, and it would help better ground us to the Newcomer character, even if he is a doorknob. But again, this is just my opinion.

I should also note that I am a person who is constantly on the verge of sensory overstimulation, so I never have music playing in games and usually have all other sounds down to 50% or less. This means I missed any music cues to the VN. Sorry. :(

Anyway, I still love where you are going with Kera. Cheers!