Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines
(2 edits) (+1)

Well for a start, I would like to point out that I'm not saying "beating her" in the argument should automatically change your overall fate (assuming that my reading of her is correct and it would be wildly out of character for her to just spare someone for talking her down). It'd be more that doing so would get Kera to actually look at you differently than just any other prey. You're making her think about it, and that's unusual.

As for how to beat the "You eat meat, I eat you" argument, a big problem with it is her framing of it. She tries to equate you eating chicken (which was raised for the sole sake of being eventually eaten, and the majority of domestic chickens and cows would be entirely incapable of living without human intervention in the first place) to her eating you alive. And she wants to eat you in a way that she actively makes things worse and more stressful for her prey, in contrast to how humans generally try to avoid making livestock unnecessarily suffer. 

Even if her argument is that she doesn't care about that aspect, it makes her entire argument unfairly biased in her own favor and hypocritical rather than accurate. On top of that, she also tries to frame it as a specific punishment towards humans, when the implications are pretty clear that she doesn't only eat humans when she hunts, so trying to go into this dark monologue about how she's a balancing factor comes across as it stands as extremely hollow. Like I said multiple times, it sounds more like she's projecting some edgy OC over herself than saying anything she actually believes.


On the topic of her not caring about the lying and such, that explanation that she doesn't care feels hollow to me from a writing standpoint. I do a lot of writing myself, and if I had a character who didn't care about lying and being manipulative, I wouldn't have them actively make a point of pride about not lying. If she doesn't care, why does she argue she never lied? That simply doesn't track. She clearly does care about being deceptive if she's going to defend her action, so her lies, direct and indirect, getting pointed out should affect her. Otherwise she should just brush the "you've lied to me" comment off with something like "Yes, your point?" rather than trying so hard to claim she never lied (which isn't true).

Also other cases she directly lied: She said while staying here she was fed MULTIPLE gourmet items (no, the "Maaaaaaaybe" response to Newcomer's incredulous question does not make it not a lie. That's still a lie, she knows exactly what she's getting Newcomer to think and it's obviously meant as a positive answer. This isn't a debatable case of "well it's only a yes from Newcomer's perspective" it's a yes from EVERY perspective.), she claims she has no idea why the dog in the park ran away after she clearly scared it herself, and there's even the argument that she lied when she referred to Newcomer multiple times as a "New Friend" as she clearly never had friendly intentions to begin with.

(Edit: On rereading this I see it came across as SIGNIFICANTLY more harsh than intended. Sorry about that, I really do like your work and am just kind of passionate about wanting to help improve it.)

(+1)

Not to worry. It was clear to me from the get-go that you got drawn into the story enough to care about it. You're just happen to be what would be considered, quite blunt.

Your points have merit, Some useful insight in there thanks.. I've already made some minor changes to the end sequence for .85, but will return to the final sequence in earnest for the next patch. I'll keep your thoughts in mind. You've already shifted .85 slightly.

Well then, I look forward to seeing what you do!