Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

AbstractLaser

153
Posts
11
Followers
7
Following
A member registered Oct 14, 2016 · View creator page →

Creator of

Recent community posts

Hi DIS,

I tried your newest build, and now it plays very smooth like a criminal! I got my behind whopped quite a lot of time in both dungeons and I could continue where I left off with smooth FPS. Also, I didn't encounter any game-breaking lag even with large enemies on the map, whereas in previous builds the game seems to slow with large enemy groups appear. 

Those Archer bosses are not push-overs, huh. I needed a few tries to really beat them. Visually big, move erratically, and shoot a very wide range, a truly terrifying goblin... I love it!

Will do. Give me a few days.

Hi Triston! Thanks for playing the game and also sharing it with your friends!

Yes, I intend to make the jobs as mini-games (or little satisfying chores) some time down the development. Although I think that they would come pretty late as there are more core issues to be tackled first (such as polishing the core gameplay loop, etc).

You brought up very fair points... the BigRealty dealing damage when they reach your room certainly is just a quick functional implementation. Like you mentioned, they should really only damage you when they damage the community as a whole. I'll need to look into how to correctly implement it.

Haha! Really appreciate sharing your friend's reactions. It's fair that he mentioned the unclear gameplay loop. I am also still experimenting with it as development goes :D

Again, thank you so much for taking the time to play and post your review! Really glad that you're interested in how the game will develop. It will take a long time before it will take its final shape, though!

(1 edit)

I think it was after I finished the first level before entering Dronghur. I was probably switching screens between ship seect, back to main menu, then go to the ability screen. Moved cards around, then pressed space bar to see the screen didn't proceed forward.

For the Void Bullet, I think the effect does the job. My impression is that it is too all-encompassing. Blacking out the whole screen and turning down the volume down to zero almost instantaneously feel like it should affect everything on the screen. However, the ability only affect whatever in its trajectory. So there is the expectation discrepancy there on my part. What I imagined is a swirling blackhole effect that gets bigger as it moves forward, while distorting the background as it moves along, and also dimming the volume slower. But this is probably a matter of personal taste.

Good to hear that the story is only the first draft. Looking forward to the updates!

Hi Vivid! Thanks for playing and the feedback. Glad you liked the one-click to move.

Hmm... thanks for pointing out the cut-off on the right and bottom side of the screen, I'll need to check it later.

Hi DIS, thanks for taking the time time to play and comment.
Your feedback never cease to amaze me!

You made a fair point regarding being able to put waypoints before executing a move. I am brainstorming and trying out solutions for the next build. Although I will try not resort to using shift-click because I want the game to be playable only using a mouse or touch. But will keep your comment in mind.

I totally missed the blurry disabled option. Thanks for pointing it out.

Hmm.. you also made a fair point regarding the new cost to the transport. I was hoping that players would not be deterred with the added cost of using the vehicles. And yes, there needs a way to put waypoints before boarding on the bus as they will drop you off if you stop moving. I'll definitely work on it immediately for the next update. 

Thank you again for your detailed feedback!
Good luck on Eldwyn's development!

Thank you for trying out the game and leaving such a great comment!

I will take into your feedback into account while developing the level next time, especially regarding unclear objectives.

It really warms my heart knowing that the game's theme come through to you! Your comment on having to utilize rallies and community building; and stand-up to fight against mega-business is what I always have in mind in throughout the development. I really appreciate your beautiful comment both the constructive criticism and the compliments.

Let's do our best!

Hi Triston, this is a very solid update! Since you've made a ton of changes, I'll also be posting much this time.
This is gonna be a long post, so prepare a popcorn and brace yourself!

Difficulty-wise. this version seems to be easier than last updates, probably to the point of being very easy. Maybe it's because I'm a recurring player? But one thing that I like this time is that Gwen's horrendous aim is so much tolerable in this version. With more focus, I could at least aim with her and do something this time around. Perhaps you tweaked her aim a bit to make it less difficult this time, and I for sure like it.

The background objects also blend-in smoother and less distracting compared to last update, good job!

For the new ability select screen, it is mostly fine. Everything is understandable from the get-go. But there are still some bugs there, yet.

First-off, when I click on repair all, sometimes the credit goes to minus values (see below). It seems that it got calculated twice.

One game-breaking bug here... after pressing shown the "ship-select" or quit button, and come back again, there is a game breaking bug where nothing happens after finishing the card selection as shown below this paragraph. Pressing space will prompt the confirmation again, but nothing also happens when you either select accept or cancel. So I had to quit the game and come back again.

Small nitpick regarding the card moving around...

So, the card slot container only detects your mouse cursor instead of the card. There are numerous times where I failed at slotting a card in because I thought it's already there, but my mouse cursor is still outside the card slot. I would love for the card slot container to detect a new card will be slotted into it without me having to precisely hover with the mouse cursor.

For illustration I am attaching a screenshot below. Let's say I want to swap Common Shield and Uplifting Aura. I grab Common Shield's upper left corner and move it over the Uplifting Aura. I would assume that since the card that I am grabbing already covers the target slot, it would just slot in. But, it failed since my mouse cursor is still outside the target slot container (since I am holding common shield's upper left corner). This is not a game-breaking one per se, but it would be more intuitive to have the card slot detect a card and apply the changes based on how much area of the grabbed card is covering the slot.



Another small nitpick I would like to see the ability to swap cards between party members quickly. Right now, I have to un-equip the card first by clicking right-click, then select another party member, and finally slot in the card that I un-equipped previously.

That's all I have for the new ability select screen. After the game-breaking bug, I quit and restarted the game.
This time, I tried using newer abilities and ships by activating the cheats.

For the newer abilities...

Before using it, I thought Saul Over would be broken, but considering that it needs 6 energy and aim, it feels quite balanced as only Gwen could have access to it at first without using max energy increase ability. I only managed to turn over 1 enemy ship into a Saul Kay before finishing the fight. 

I tried using the void bullet twice. And the screen just went blank while killing the user (Gwen) in the process the first time I used it. The second time, I moved her a bit further in front and fire the void bullet, she managed to survive with low health and insta-kill the boss. I don't know what to think about this ability though... probably I would not want to use it in my strategy in a normal play.

I didn't get to try out the Anachronium Wave, since it doesn't really have any new effect for me as a player. I don't consider adding a new turn for your team is a new gameplay effect. Although I can see it as a viable strategy in a normal play. Since for this playtest, I mostly want to know the new abilities effect, so I skipped trying out this one since it's understandable just by reading the description.

For Meteor Shower, this is one of those classic high-damaging move. One nitpick I have with it seems to have not so much visual impact. I imagine meteor showers to come flying at a high speed, so although it has a considerable gamplay effect, visually it lacks the power for me.

Regarding the new ships...

It gets a bit of getting used to, but Gwen can be a monster with the massive energy prod while low health. I could either spam the shield or Saul Kay with her. But I feel this has a good balance for a high-risk/high-reward play.

For the Kunai ship, that is a good trade-off of having diminished aim plus +1 energy with every basic shot. Nice touch! I don't know why, but I find it harder to aim with lesser aim circumference. Somehow, this makes Gwen's aim on a similar level with Kunai.

For Flinn, his upgraded ship just rocks, no comment on it.

For your remaining questions...
Since you are the designer and developer of the game, you are the one that should be answering these, right? 
But hey, I'll play along and try to answer them :D

Steam worthiness in its current state

I would say it has a nice polished quality, especially in the UI/UX department. Content-wise, it has enough ability cards to encourage different play-style. So, I think it's worthy as a demo game. Compared to the low-effort/low-quality games that are flooding Steam, Anachrnoium (Time Crusader) is the kind of games that I would like to see it being put there. 

Weakest part of the game and the best.

Weakest part: Slow story pacing
Best part: Polished UI/UX

What sets this game apart from other games?

I would say... the game is trying to mix two different play styles of "turn-based strategy" (positioning, timing, and ability selection) and "skill-based" (with the aim). It does it quite well thematically. I don't know this kind of game already existed or not, so I can't tell what would set this game apart from similar games. But one thing for sure is that gameplay mechanics and UI have strong thematic cohesion.

What are the four things that you consider to be a part of the game loop?

1. Energy accumulation / setting up defenses / heal -> Damaging enemies -> repeat 
2. Battle -> trying out newly unlocked abilities/ship -> repeat
3. Level Victory -> Story -> repeat

I can't think of another more.

That's it for now, this post is already long enough so I'll stop it here.
Ask me around if you have any specific questions.

Overall, I felt that you've made a ton of progress and everything (except story) has been improved overall.
Great job!

Ah! I must have missed that when Vega mentioned it, apologies.

No worries, although the pacing may be slow in general, it does have thematic cohesion. So I didn't see it in a negative was; just pointing it out.

Your Day 1 experience plays very solidly for me, looking forward to the unraveling of events!

(1 edit)

For my feedback, I can't evade mentioning anything without spoiling the story, so...

!!! Spoiler Alert !!!

----

Firstly, it's good that you have the disclaimers at the start regarding sensitive topics.

I find the first when where Vega spends too much time in their room and house. It feels like the pacing is too slow for me. But due to the overthinking native, it has a narrative cohesion. Honestly, there was just too much monologue for my taste. But to each their own. I would look into trimming some monologue that doesn't really serve a narrative purpose. Since you're hinting that something big is happening on the fourth day at the beginning, I was looking forward to what transpired until that time. The pace only picks up when we're at the Abandoned Church. 

Vega mentioned that they wasted most of their twenties rotting inside the room. From It feels more like Vega is still a teenager or just early twenties. The dialog and how the group also sounds more like teenagers instead of fully grown-adults. From my experience, by late twenties most people would be already too busy with lives instead of visiting your basement to practice band. Unless they're really passionate about music, and even if that is the case, taking break from a whole month will not work well for your music career. But who knows, maybe the characters in the story are already somewhat successful in their career to afford the break. These are the discrepancies that I'm struggling to reconcile in my head while playing.

Some comments on the UI...

In the selection UI (e.g. in the Abandoned Church when choosing to go to the Sun Room or Graveyard), I find it unusual that the border also expands vertically when you hover on the option. It must be that the size of the border scale together with the size of text, and when the text get slightly bigger when you hover them, the border also get bigger. 

The UI at the bottom of the screen is decent enough to not be cluttering the space. It would probably be a bit better if the options can automatically hide itself  when your mouse cursor is not hovering them. I am saying this because the dialog window is also at the bottom half of screen, so hiding the UI when you're not hovering them will put more focus on the dialog window for better immersion. The last option only says "sett", while it's easy to know that it's settings, why not just show the full word? 

The rhythm mini-game at the end is such a fresh break from all the dialog! I was playing on PC with a keyboard. It may be worth trying with using different keys for the inputs as opposed to the arrow keys. Since the character is playing a bass with vertical four buttons, maybe using key layouts of the following (using right hand) would be worth experimenting:

"space-bar" -> thumb 
"N" key - index finger 
"J" key - middle finger
"I"key - ring finger

I think this will align thematically more with the layout of the game and bass instrument.

The rhythm and button timing seems a little bit off for me, but since it is not-punishing, I think I did pretty well. Since this is mostly a narrative visual novel, I'd put a lower priority for it compared to the writing/narrative.

---

End of Spoiler

Overall, this is a decent visual novel, I enjoyed my time playing it and made it until the end of Day 1+ the 10 questions personal assessment. Although the pacing is too slow for my taste and the content is still lacking, it is an overall pleasant experience to go through the demo. I do look forward to know what will happen in the full demo!

Good luck on the development!

This is  quite a fun litle puzzle game! Blobs interactions are well polished. The sound effects are also very cute and has different tones when the blobs interact. The game lacks a background music playing (the only needed improvement that I can point of), but it doesn't feel like it need one anyway. The flow of the puzzle (ramping difficulty and variety), visual polish, and sound effects are enough to engage me through all the levels.

I am not a big puzzle gamer, and I find the controls and rules very intuitive, so good job on the on-boarding. Overall, I completed all the demo levels in under 30 min. I didn't get stuck per se, but spent an embarrassingly long time on the second last level of the reef.

Regarding on the feelings that I get from interacting with the blobs... I can only describe what I felt while playing. Please don't take it as any suggestion to change.

It's weird... some of the blobs give me some eerie feelings. They look cute and repulsive at the same time. The ones I find cute are those in The Common (the angry/happy levels).  For the repulsive ones, it is The Reef level blobs where they have appendages around them. They definitely feel like virus or one-celled-bacteria trying to eat each other. Those are more on the repulsive side than cute. I was also taken aback when presented with the three-eyed blobs near the start of the game. If this eerie feeling between cute/repulsive is what you're aiming for, you did a pretty good job. 

Overall, this is a good little puzzle game! It scratches the simple problem-solving itch while also eliciting some emotions. I would definitely see these kinds of games being played inside a commuter train or waiting for your turn at the dentist' office. Good job!

Hi Vivid!

Regarding the new mini-games, I like putting the cat pads on the floor so that nearby cats will run to it. I don't use the extra pats that much. But these extra interactions bring quite a charm to the game.

Since you're asking about bugs, changes, or edits. I didn't ran into any particular bugs as I played it.
Things I would definitely add to add more enjoyment for the game is having more distinct cat behaviors. The flavor text when adopting cats mention they have different personalities, but as you adopt them, they all seem to behave very similarly. It would be immensely better if they have different behavior that can be understood at a glance. One thing as an example that I can think of is that shier cats would probably stay closer to the edge of the cafe, so that customer need to walk to them to play with them. The thing is, after you adopted the cat, you can't really read the flavor text of each cat's personality anymore (can you?). Which is OK as long as there is a distinct way to tell their personalities apart from their visual movement or behavior.
Let me know if you're already working on it so I don't have to comment these next time :D

Also, since you have different mouse cursor for the mini-games... Maybe it would add some charm if there also unique cursors when hovering the cats to increase their comfort and hovering over the players to get the cash.

I like that you made some changes to the cafe as you make the upgrades! Particular, I was slowly maxing out the furniture to level 30, and can definitely see the changes as you level them up. Although, I would love to see more drastic changes between level. Currently, the difference is quite sparse, but it is at least something rather than none. This is probably the current weakness of the game that I feel. The current upgrade progression, doesn't bring that enough anticipation, yet.

Small nitpicks from me regarding the cat sprites. Some of the cats look almost identical to each other, such as Luna and Snow, both have white sprites. So I can't tell whom are whom when they're running around without hovering on them. It would be great if you could add some stripes to just differentiate them. Also is the same for Nyx and Bandit, while they have slightly different shade, they're pretty much identical at a glance.

I felt the game has improved considerably in terms of polish compared to last time.  The effects when the cats are dashing, and when they interact with customers are so lovely. Good on job on the progress!

Since I have played this game last time, I don't have any further comment on the level designs. For now, I'll start with commenting on the updates and finish with some thoughts since you mentioned that this will be released commercially in a month. The comments I have for this time will probably sound more negative since I will only be mentioning issues from my part. But to start, you did a very good job on the level design as they have a very nice flow of difficulty and advancement.

Achievement Systems

I find the explicit achievement pop-ups seems to be too excessive, especially at the beginning of the gameplay.
So.. I first went through the trap dungeon. Then there is this enemy that spawn right on top of the switch that causes the trap to shoot arrow and the enemy just got killed right there. I got the achievement of killing the enemy even though I didn't do anything. I can understand if I lure the enemies into the pit and get the achievement. But I think you shouldn't get any achievement for not doing anything.

I don't think this system adds anything good extra to the game, . But it may be because I'm used to playing games where there are no achievements at all; or the achievements are of little quantities and much harder to achieve.

Camera Zoom

For the new camera zoom level, I played with zoomed-in size of around 1.7x and find it OK for the most part. The default settings seem to be OK at least. In fact, there are some levels that makes you more handicapped while playing in zoomed in, such as levels with goblin archers. I got killed once just because the enemies were off-screen and they fired their arrows at me without me knowing they're there. And after that experience, I tend to leave the camera zoom level at default or even smaller (more view of the game level). Personally, I prefer to play with between 1.3x up to 1.5x zoom level.

Performance Issues

This may only be a personal problem, but I want to put this out just for awareness. 
The game frame-rate always suffer whenever I died and choose continue. And there's no way to properly play the game with this since the attack animation got cut-off before the slashing frame and there seems to be no hit-box to damage the enemies. The trap dungeon is also unsolvable due to needing precise movement and timing to evade the arrows shooting.
Strangely enough, the frame-rate always return to normal whenever I go to the main-menu and restart the game from the beginning. So maybe there are something leaking while choosing the "continue" option instead of "main menu".
So I tried to replay the game every time I died, I couldn't finish the game in one go. Although, I did get very far with each dungeon, defeating bosses and get the different power-ups. I stopped playing after about 1 hour.

Little comments on the control

It seems that there is a very little acceleration and de-acceleration with the movement. While it is very tiny, it plays fine for the most part. Except for the tiny bit where you need precise control to properly evade the arrows in the Trap Dungeon. I wonder if it would be better if there are no accel/de-accel at all. But the movement control is fine as it is.

Overall

Except for the polish, I think the game is doing fine as a SNES-style Zelda-like game. Since you are aiming for a release in one month time (or less), I would recommend to polish the game extra hard before release. I still find some rough part that feels more like a placeholder instead of production quality. Such as pick-up SFX being the same whether they're food (bread), coins, or arrow. And then there are walls with purple lines that players can't cross but the wind wand can go through. Speaking of the wind effect, the curly sprite is just not polished enough as a production quality. Since it can move blocks, it should have more "power/impact/pressure" feel to it.

 There are too many little things that I still find unpolished but I'm sure you are working on it. Everything that is tied directly to player's interaction will need extra priority, while background art can take more of a back-seat. 

And hey, thanks for including the classroom intro with Eldwyn the dragon sprite as oppose to the placeholder Pegasus sprite. At least the narrative is more coherent now compared to last time.

Good luck on the final sprint before release, Godspeed!

Thanks! It's really encouraging to hear some excitement from a fellow gamedev :D

Hi Wandering Songbird, thank you for playing the game and writing such beautiful comment.
Really appreciate that you describe how you feel about the changes.

Also, I apologize for the soft-locks to be game-breaking. Will definitely fix this in the near future, and probably do a quick upload for this specific fix.

Hey Triston, thank you for playing and leaving an awesome feedback!

I was thinking along similar line to suggestion for the bus mechanic, but I'll need some time to figure out how to really implement them. One of the problems of having them moving around is making the screen too cluttered/busy. But since you mentioned it, it pushed me to take a step forward in doing so, I'll consider implementing moving buses.

Hmm... I'll look into the game crashing while establishing buildings. Thanks for reporting it.

The reactivate only changes the zone type to a different one. I do agree that it was not communicated enough in the game, as there is only small text (somewhere in Control Tip on the top of the screen). 

Really glad that you could enjoy the game! 
I truly appreciate the offer! But I'll make some updates first before daring to request for another playtest :D

IIRC, when I went back to the story mode again, I had to start from the very beginning with the starting credits and abilities. But it was only a couple of battles before I hit the exit button, so there wasn't much progress anyway. Perhaps it didn't get saved because I haven't completed the whole 3 battles in the first mission yet?

Thanks for the screenshot! This is very helpful, I think I know the reason and will adjust to fit everything in the next fix!

Hi Vivid, thanks for playing the game and the feedback!

Yeah, I was having a hard time with the screen resolution settings and such, I really need to dedicate a time to resolve it for the next build.
I am really sorry if this causes further unnecessary confusion as there are crucial info for gameplay. Such as increasing Fame that you earn while getting tokens, and the small blinking low Loudness indication when it's not enough. I am very glad hearing that it's more engaging for you this time!

If it's possible, could you please describe how the cut-off at the bottom of the screen look like? 

Yup, I didn't check the character stat screen after looking at the key item. 

No worries, I was only reporting on how many items I managed to send back and how hypothetically how far I could stretch it.

Just an idea, perhaps instead of only total number of items, wouldn't it be more engaging if the town requests a number of specific type of items? Similar to a fetch quest in other games. Let's say, your town requests a certain of fire-type food, or earth-type food. It will create a small decision point in which you think: if I send earth-type food now, Tanko will have less consumables to use his abilities. So on so forth with other types of food. And the reward you get back is also specific to tied to the request. Just my 2 cents.

I gave the game a second go this time to play the story mode and see what the reward for the quest is all about. It feels good that our town gave us little reward for sending all the items. Looking at the key item description, I am assuming that by having it all the party members gain more max HP. Honestly, I didn't really feel that much of a difference. Although its effect is underwhelming, at least it feels good that we get a little reward for sending out items. Perhaps I was expecting an item that unlock a special ability, or high-level consumables. 

Then, I gave an honest shot to try to reach the next goal, but 10,000 items is too much. The highest I could send back was around 3,500 items before reaching Wildemore. Maybe if I pushed out sending more items back, I could've reached 4,000 items. But hitting 10,000 feels impossible for now.

Speaking about the trade depot screen... I still see the duplicated items bug as seen below: There are triple slice of jerkies (6 slices). When I right-click on one of them, they got moved to the top of the screen and merged into 1 set of 6 slices of jerkies.


Hi Triston, the update you made the game feel comparatively better than I played last month.

Before I answer the feedback you specifically requested, I want to share about my play this time.

Since I finished the demo campaign already, I only did a couple of the story battles. Did a couple purchase, moving around the ability cards, and then went back to the main menu by pressing the "power-icon" at top-right of the screen. I was a bit surprised that the progress I made during the campaign was lost when I started the Battle mode. Since it was only a couple levels, so it's not a big deal. I would suggest you to look into the continuity between the Story and the Battle mode.

For the Battle Mode, I managed to only get to the 3rd battle. The enemy one-shotted Oyster W and Flinn on the 2nd battle, leaving me with only Valkyrie. Thankfully, there is one Saul Kay deployed by this time, and the enemy unit that does attack is low on health. So, with the Saul Kay, I killed the attacking enemy unit, leaving only the support enemies that can't attack you. But since Valkyrie's aim is just so awful, I deployed up to 5 Saul Kays in this battle! Earning the "Saul Right" and "Dragon Isle" Badge! (Hey! That's a nice shout-out to the host of this jam!). While waiting to deploy the number of Saul Kays, there is one that has the Hubble Telescope card to decrease the aim, so I use a bunch of that on Valkyrie to reduce the aim circumference. Even after around 5+ uses of Hubble Telescope, Valkyrie's aim is just too awful for me to use. But I did manage to defeat a couple of enemies with her. 

So now this leave me only with Valkyrie for the next Battle... But hey, let's try the Saul Kay strategy again and see how long we can last. The 3rd battle is the boss that do recharge -> phantom laser, recharge -> flower-patterned attack. It is just too strong, so I only managed to deploy 2 Saul Kays before getting obliterated. 

But man... the 2nd battle with Valkyrie and a fleet of Saul Kays was a memorable experience for me :D

Is the on-boarding experience smooth?

I didn't play the tutorial and just went straight to the campaign mode. The first few battles are easy enough for players to make some mistakes and still be able to win. UI is understandable, so I don't see any problems with it. One small I would point is that.. When you are moving a character's ship, the ability cards have high visibility, as if that you can click on the card mid-move. There are so many times that I just clicked on the ability cards mid-move but mistaken that I had to end the move first. Perhaps, disabling the highlight of ability cards mid-move may help a bit with this.

Is this a game you would recommend to your friends?

It depends on the friends, I would recommend it to either to someone who like outer-space spaceship battle games, or fellow game-devs.

Are the reactive dialogues in the way? Or do they add to the experience.

They're short-and-sweet, and didn't stop the flow of the game, so they definitely add to my experience. I love it when characters respond to what I'm doing. Also, another small bug... when you place your ship close to the top of screen, the dialog gets cut-off and you can't see what they're saying.

What do you think of the spaceship designs?

They're good enough, I like that you add some blinking light on it to make them more important.

Since I am working on SFX I would appreciate any feedback on that.

Sound effects are mostly fine. I like that almost every button hover and presses have a small SFX to them, making it very responsive and nice to play navigate. The healing SFX just sounds like metallic parts being assembled. While it may make sense, I just can't help but find it a little bit jarring.

How does the background feel? too much? needs toning down?

Compared to the last update, there may be more variety to the background, but I feel their movement may be too much to the point that it's a little tad distracting. Or maybe they have vivid contrast with the black outer space color that makes them distracting. Perhaps, toning it just a little bit down may help.

One point regarding the control... 
When using keyboard to move, did you change so that you move forward with "D" key instead of "W"? And backwards with "A" key instead of "S"? I find myself mistaking it a lot of time and wasting fuels this time. Perhaps the last key-binding was a more intuitive for me. But well, this a matter of preference so please take it with a grain of salt.

Overall, I feel the game has quite a polished quality to it, great job!

Regarding the UI position on abilities, sorry for not being precise with my words. Yes, I meant bottom middle part of the screen, not dead center. But you got my point. More importantly than exact position of each UI though, I think it's worth just experimenting with bringing relevant info UI closer together. And pushing less relevant info to the edge of the screen. Perhaps not all AP need to be shown since a Slime character can only get some type of AP. Also, I never ever worried about affinity since it's such a small difference, so it always felt irrelevant for me. But yeah, please experiment more with the battle UI, I think it will have lots of merit as it will be the main interface for players.

(1 edit)

Hi DIS and Wandering Songbird,

The slime movement animation felt more natural than before. Once you execute an ability, the attack/heal/buff animation a little bit more of umph into it, I can't explain it very well with words, but other words, executing a move felt a little bit better than before. So overall good job on the animation updates!

One small thing regarding the sound effect when your slime party members get hit.. it sounds like stepping on a puddle. I know that since they're slimes, they may produce that kind of sound. But it just feels a little bit jarring/underwhelming. Since enemy attacks are supposed to be hurtful and they're attacking with sharp objects and explosive magics. So I am expecting more impactful sound when being hit.

I like that for Mindy's elemental abilities get more categories and you can now expand/collapse on them, nice touch! Although, once she learns higher-level abilities, there seem to be no point on casting the lower-levelled ones. In other RPGs, usually it cost less, but here, some of the higher-level abilities that doesn't cost AP just has the same cost to the lower-levelled ones. Same is also true for other Slime's abilities. I still don't know what to think of it whether if it's positive/negative, just mentioning. 

On the UI...

I've never mentioned this before since it is mostly a personal thing. I find that the ability selection buttons, AP info UI, and enemy are separated quite far. After playing for 10 min or so, my eyes get tired from darting from left to right, up and down the screen. Maybe, it is worth trying to change some of the UI positioning to be closer together. One thing I would definitely try is to put the move selection at the middle of the screen instead of the left-side. And another thing I would try is somehow move the AP info bar close to the move selection screen, although this will be quite a rework on the UI positioning. I like to check how much AP I have before doing a move, to know which AP I want to increase or use for the turn. So, it may benefit to putting them closer together.

This time, I played the endless mode in normal difficulty. Managed to all the abilities and to 2 other Inn Towns and a couple of battles. I stopped at the point when the enemy one can one-shot my party members on their turn. At first, I still tried to revive and heal to my best ability. But once the healer was finished, well that's it. I stopped playing around 50min to 1hour mark. But I think the Normal difficulty has a nice curve to it, good job!

I have yet to check the quest reward, will do so later tomorrow and report back in this comment thread.

Hi T, thanks for playing the game and the beautiful comment!
No need for apologies... we're all here to play, review, and be better developer. Your feedback is so helpful in understanding how the changes will work for better or worse. I'm taking notes and will think over how to go on next.

Yup, you're right. You should be able to interact at the Cafe just to replenish energy, that is also another bug. I'll fix it in future releases.

Thanks for reporting the bugs. I will need to check on the soft-lock you reported. Having more rallied than resident is totally possible if you rally from the Cafe. The furniture staying after replay was a mistake on my part for not clearing it after finishing the level. I didn't expect players to replay the game after finishing one, so I didn't manage to clear all the furniture data. Oopsie..:D

Again, thank you for taking the time to play and leave an awesome feedback.

Hi!

With the title Doughborn and the merchant saying, "Oh, you're finally awake."... you're making reference to Skyrim, aren't you? :D

I'm not a fan of horror games since I get spooked easily. I could say that the game delivers on the overall horror experience quite well. The opening scene really reminds me of waking up in the middle to go to the restroom or take a sip of water. Great job on creating the overall atmosphere! I am glad that I played it in the middle of the day :D

Pacing-wise, I feel everything seems in place. The tutorials come up at the appropriate timing. Good job!

The controls are fine. The hint comes up as you play the game and every interaction keys are quite clear. I don't see any problem with it. 

In total, I played the game 2 times. I died of hunger on the first time. Sometimes, when I open a chest, I get some food like chicken, dough, etc that shows up on the top-right of the screen under the doughnut bars. I assume that you can consume these foods to replenish the hunger bar, but there's not any tutorial on it. I tried pressing a bunch of keys on the keyboard and nothing happened. So, maybe this is just unimplemented feature.

Regarding bugs...

After I replayed the game by clicking restart. The previous hint label "E - to Exit" was still there as I died from hunger while hiding. Fortunately the hint label get replaced as new instructions come. I suspect that this is unexpected small bug.

In the second playthrough, I played by moving faster so that I can avoid dying from hunger... only then died being attacked by the monster. Then, I clicked on main menu but the play screen keeps on going, the main menu just didn't show up. This is the only technical bug that I encountered so far.

I saw on the game page that it's also supposed to be a stealth game. Since the camera angle is 2D side-scrolling, I find it very hard to do stealth since there's just no way of telling when the monster is coming.  This is currently more like a horror side-scroller walking game, rather than a stealth horror. But with that being said, overall, the current demo convey the horror atmosphere quite well and it's a pleasant (and spooky) experience to play. Good job!

Thank you for the suggestion about the screen size. I was having quite a difficult time with it, but decided to move on and work on the game instead. I will dedicate a block of time and try out your suggestion for the next builds.

Oof... I wasn't expecting such a reaction on the randomized zoning system. Yeah, I do agree that it's unacceptable to consecutively get the same zoning. I just did a hot-fix patch to address this. I do want to keep the randomization to keep the "activate" option to a minimum as not to clutter the screen and make it more seamless. Hopefully other playtesters will not experience this frustration. But thank you so much for pointing this out! I will adjust the rules as development go.

The glitching bus and protest when the bus station is next to the BigRealty is definitely an issue. I will have to fix this next time, please bear with it for the current one. 

I really appreciate you playing the game and providing a detailed feedback on the new mechanics!
I am taking notes with this and will definitely adjust the game based on this.

Hi! Thank you the comment, it's totally OK to take your time. 

Just want to remind you that the game is still in the early stage of experimentation and janky. I am also making fixes, adjustments, and changes as time goes on, so it's totally fine if you can come back in a couple months. I am very delighted to even hearing that you want to cover the game :D

Hi DIS and Wandering Songbird !

The voice acting is a very good addition to the game. I like having a sense of human touch in a game, makes it more organic.

I played the game twice, first with tutorial on and the second time just wandering around a bit. On the first tutorial screen, I find it a little odd that the dialog box covers the player character on the bottom half of the screen. And we have to go through all the dialog before being able to control the character. Since the game is already intuitive, I think it benefit more of having only a voice-over while also being able to move around, without having to sit through the dialog. Not to mention that the game comes off more of an action-adventure game where players' skills are being exercised, rather than a story-based game. I feel that the room is big enough to fit in several sentences while you traverse through them. There are easy rooms, like the tutorial, or the first screens of the dungeons that can be experimented with having voice-over instead of a forced dialog.

All the unicorn instructors that was shown in the dialog box feels like they come out of nowhere. They're not even in the game play screen, just appear on the dialog box. Perhaps showing the their sprites animation at the Main Menu will ease into this feeling. But I totally understand if the arts/audio are mostly placeholders at this stage, just want to mention it here.

On the level design...  
I think you did a great job here on the design, and the difficulty curve is very appropriate. Food/Ammo numbers are good.

Enemies and their placements in the Goblin Dungeons are good. I also like that after you get a new equipment, the subsequent rooms immediately showcase the new equipment. Particularly, the room with long corridors after you get the boulder wand, it's satisfying to roll the boulder on the enemy in a straight line. Just a small tidbit from me is that, you cannot roll the boulder when you touch the wall, the boulder got destroyed immediately. Since the corridor is quite small in width, I find myself always touching the wall when doing a turn, and then casting a boulder that immediately gone when touching the walls.

Puzzles are not instantly obvious, but solutions come up after a few seconds, and solvable in matter of couple minutes. Except the room with the wind wand where you have to move 2 blocks, I moved the blocks too far by spamming the wind wand and have to reset the room twice :D oopsie on my part. But overall, the puzzles are quite engaging for me to want to keep moving forward.

On the controls...
I played the game using a keyboard with WASD and JKL + space to attack/dash. The game is almost wholly playable with a keyboard, except when having to change the tools. I can open the inventory pressing the "I" key, but it seems that I had to resort to using the mouse to select them. It would be cool if you can also navigate the inventory using the keyboard WASD and equip them using the "J" and "K" keys. 

On the sound...
Since the game is still early with placeholders, I may give a pass for now. But I hope there will be a differentiation in the SFX when you collect health, coins and mana-restore items.

Another moment of delight is the mini-boss room :D I find it cute and terrifying at the same because the mini-boss has a much bigger sprite and immediately walk around then try to attack you when you enter the room.

All in all, the game played and felt better in this update compared to a couple of months ago. Although the theming execution and contents need a lot more work, I think It is slowly shaping up to be a decent action-adventure mini-game. Good work!

Hi VividEnigma,

The game has quite noticeable QoL improvements since I last played, good job! 

You mentioned of updates on the minigames, but are there minigames other than the laser pointer? For an idle incremental game, using the laser pointer is fun. I like to purchase the laser pointer and guide the chaotic cats movement for a brief period of time. It really breaks the monotony of cats moving in a chaotic random movement. But since "chaos" in the title, then perhaps this is all by design. Again, the laser-pointer is a great supplemental addition to the game.

Another thing I like is how all the buttons are very polished. You did a great job on making the UI/UX pleasant to navigate. One small nuisance is when money is not enough to do a purchase/upgrade, all the flavor text got replaced by "not enough money". I think it would be slightly better if the flavor text is kept displayed as is, then  "not enough money" indication somewhere else.

Q. What is confusing or seems unclear?

I wonder why when the earned money pops up, it also shows 1 digit behind the decimal point such as $25.0. It's not confusing in a bad way per se, it just adds a little bit of unnecessary clutter to the screen. But again, since "chaos" is in the title, it may not be a bad thing. Just wondering here...

Also, the win-state of the game does not seem to be clearly defined. I got the pop-up that won the game at level 89 with all cats adopted, and all upgrades except coffee hovering around level 10+. My money was very low when the victory pop-up shows up. But in the beginning it says to earn a lot of money to win the game.

In the cat adoption and upgrade screen, I feel the icons are quite big but the resolution is too small. From what I can tell it's 16x16 pixel taking up a third of the screen height. I think the resolution is just too small for its size. There's room for experiments here to add a little bit more details, especially to the cat (adding emotions according to their personalities would make the game come more alive). Maybe trying 24x24 or 32x32 would gain lots of merit without taking too much time.

Q. What changes could make game more engaging?

(1) When I purchased the ball upgrade, my first reaction is to click on it. So, I would like to being able to click on the ball and see them bounce around the cafe. This would definitely add the "toy"-feel to the game.

(2) Also, having different animations for different cats based on their personalities when you click on them. In addition to adding variety to the game, this also creates the anticipation of adopting new cats.
 

Q. Did you enjoy the game?

For an incremental idle game and knowing the state of the project, I quite enjoyed it. The game still lacks content to make me want to go back again, but I think you would address this as you develop the game. The visuals and audio really work well together bringing a relaxing atmosphere. So overall, great job!

Thank you for playing the game in its unstable state. 

I deeply appreciate the time you put in to stream and for your feedback.

Hi Triston!

With more  experience this time, I managed to finish all levels without game-over! Funny thing is, I got 2 ships destroyed on the first level (before reaching Dronghur). I am glad the ships got revived on going to the next level. Then after the cutscene, I played the side-quest mission against the stationary boss before going to level 2. I think it really helped me with getting better at the game since the boss has lots of HP and is stationary; so as to serve as a practice mission. This kinda make me think that the enemies for the first few levels are too small to aim at (maybe personal skill issue?). But all in all, I think the difficulty has been toned down since I last played and it now has a better curve.

My strategy is as follow

- Valkyrie as main support to cast shields, healing-aura and dispatch saul-kays since her aim is just too unreliable. I like saul-kay a lot since it is practically an extra unit and moreover, it has randomized skill cards for me to try out. I think Saul-Kay was very crucial in winning the game for me, haha!

- Flinn as the main DPS. I like using sniper legacy with him. It's very satisfying when you get perfect aim with long distance!

- Oyster is more like a wild-card for me with shield, blast-gun, energy restoration, and heal (the rain heal). 

More things that I enjoyed from this playtest:

- The random stuffs that come floating around is such a nice addition to aid you. And sometimes when you shoot several of them, they just have this chaotic effect that can aid you. It feels refreshing to hit several of them in one shot and see various effects come into play.

- I see there are variety in the background now which is nice! Maybe dimming the galaxies/stars brightness a bit to make it blend together into the background will improve the visual readability a bit.

Some things that bugged me:

- The background music can be very repetitive since it is quite short and looping. Having longer song or multiple songs may alleviate it. 

- The victory background music seem to stop after a while (around after 2 minutes). I noticed it when I take a bit of break, then come back to play and didn't hear any sound.

- An undo button would be good. I tend to mis-clicked an ability or finished move on accidents.

- Related to movement, I felt that the fuel got spent quite fast. There are times that I find myself in a very bad aiming spot after moving and have to forfeit the turn. Perhaps making aiming free of fuel may alleviate this, but I am sure you have tested a bunch and decided on making the aim to require fuel. So I'm still not sure about this, just mentioning it.

- I would like to see more abilities that don't require any energy to be available earlier in the game. When I unlocked the recharge ability, I was using it basically almost every turn to charge for bigger abilities. Before having recharge, I didn't use higher-cost abilities that much except for Saul Kay. 

- The initial cut-scene art style felt jarring for me in a way that I can't explain very well. Maybe it's the girl's impression that is a little bit uncanny for me.

But overall, I think the game is shaping up to be quite good! The game ended on a good cliff-hanger. I really want to know what will happen next. Also, I find the game very enjoyable after getting better at positioning and aiming (mostly aiming). I didn't realize 2 hours had gone by playing it!

Let me know if you have any questions, cheers!

Hi!

I tried out the tutorial and here are my impressions and feedback.

At first, the camera can be disorienting since you can move in 6 directions. But since the game is in outer-space, it does make sense thematically. And after playing a while, I could manage it. The control also took some time getting used to. But after getting used to both the control and camera, it's actually fun to move around and shoot at things!

I can't play the single-player mode since the frame-rate is hovering below 10FPS (maybe it's because I am running the game on a 8-year-old PC). But even then, I think there are far too many objects hovering in the level. So I only did the tutorial. But still, I could not finish the tutorial because it's so easy to get lost. Perhaps making the move space more bounded would be better. Or having a more distinct marker so that players have a clear destination will also work. When Petra said she had marked the gate (the one similar to the sun symbol), I just couldn't find it after moving in random directions, so I replayed the tutorial. But on the next tutorial session, I got lost trying to find the goal marker for the boost tutorial.

There is a visual bug where I paused the game to look at the control help, the tutorial prompt is on top of the pause-screen. I suppose the tutorial tip would be under the pause screen so sharing it here just in case. Here is a screenshot of it:


Regarding the Lock-On... it says that it will center on the target. Does it mean like auto-focus? or follow on the target? At least that's what I assumed. But apparently, it just lock the camera so you can't aim on the moving targets. I kinda felt cheated with the feature.

To end on more positive notes, here are the things that I like....

The visual is amazing! I like that there are variations of colors and gradients as you move through space. The UI and HUD are also properly designed. One little thing that bugs me is the somewhat thick black outline on your ship. It gives a toon-ish tone to the game, which clash a bit with the overall visual. But anyway, great job on the visual.

The game has great background music too, it  complements the gameplay and atmosphere well. The synth sound gives a sense of outer-space. Every sound effect is well-designed and the human voices when you toggle inertia damping or the turret mode is properly placed. It adds a small sense of comfort in the lonely outer-space.

Great job in the visual and audio department!

Overall, I did enjoy moving around and shooting things even though I didn't get to experience the main content of the game. Then... although it needs a little bit of time to getting used to, the control has good sense of feedback to interact it. I would say for now, the game has a very good "toy"-like feature to play in it.

Hi Triston,

Thanks for putting in the time to playtest and the feedback! I like how you explained your gameplay, which give me an estimate on what needs to be worked on in the next iteration.

I am so happy that you complimented on the sound effects! I did spend extra time and effort on them. Most of them are royalty-free license from Pixabay then tweaked in Audacity to give the game feel.

Hmm... it's interesting that you mention the movement system is lacking. The double-click to move was a design intent on my part. Did you build any logistics, such as bus stations/stops, parking lot or gas-stations? If you walk past them, the character will ride the vehicle until the movement stop. So as to encourage efficient movement; thus multiple waypoint systems are implemented, and you can only move with a double-click on the same place. But thank you for pointing this out! This really highlight that the full movement mechanic hasn't been communicated well enough.

A web build has only been recently uploaded on the game page. However, I am still fiddling around them because the FPS is still lacking (on Firefox) and to be improved on. Thank you for mentioning this, I'll try my best to make it work for the next update.

As suggestions for the next play, try to build as much buildings as possible and don't stress too much on the energy :D You can just go back to the Room to Rest/Sleep. I intend to make the game easy and forgiving even with a very inefficient play. But reading from your comment, it means that the current build is still too punishing for an easy/casual play. The difficulty will be somewhat toned down in the future builds and hopefully it can be more enjoyable.

I didn't see your game too while browsing the submission list, must have been buried under a bunch of so many games. But I will make time over this weekend to play and give some feedback! Looking forward to it!

Hi DIS,

Looking at your recent devlog, I'll be commenting mainly on animations. But overall it's a good update.

The use of slime hopping animation is somewhat Cute. It just seems a little uncanny since they jump in unison. Perhaps adding some variations in timing would break it.

I see there are now also split-second animations while doing attacks/heals. I will assume that they're all still placeholders as they're only doing spit animations regardless of what item being used for the actions. Just a thought here... if all the actions will eventually share the same spit animation, maybe the item choosing can all be removed? Or be heavily simplified to only how much items you want to consume for the ability? (such as consuming more creating better effects and vice-versa). Although the changes over the months since I followed the game has shown better progress in the inventory area. The overwhelming options to choose when performing abilities has always been a lingering pain point for me. It also doesn't help when all the items don't their own distinct animation (yet? I hope). When playing RPG, seeing new abilities and their animations is one of the exciting part. If all the abilities are the same, having tons of options just doesn't serve any purpose for me.

The rain/dust effects on the overworld is such a nice eye-candy! Maybe show some dandelion floating around when I dandelionrow would be fitting! Just a bit nitpicky from me... When the screen goes dark when you stay at the inn, the effect doesn't go away. I would expect the effect to be going away since your characters are indoors. 

On the AP display above... I think players can understand and will eventually pick up that using a basic ability will increase certain AP; and it cost AP to use higher-level abilities. It would be nice if there's a small animation/effect that shows that info when performing the ability. Like when you use a basic slash, a small slash AP+ effect shows up; when you use a multi-slash attack, slash AP- effect shows up. It can be any kind of visual effect just to show it, like a charge or discharge effect will do the job too.

I was playing on easy mode and it's nice to be able to not stressout too much on battles and just enjoy the story. 

Hi DIS!

Thanks for checking out the update. I am glad the changes were mainly positive so far.

And thanks for your feedback and mentioning the game state throught out.

The room and cafe screen definitely need serious re-design to make them more relevant. It is good that you can still win the game without relying on the Cafe though, that indicates the game being not too punishing.

You are right regarding The mafia request consequences. Currently, it's only a first crude implementation where the enemy has higher defense and they will send out more agents. It definitely needs re-design some time in the future.

I saw your game on the submission list too and was thinking to block out a time in the weekend for it to review over. Looking forward to it!

Definitely, Nujabes' beats also came up to my mind when playing your game, haha! With the theme you're aiming for, I am sure there'll lots of people who like it, I am one of them. Make sure to include the defiant character in the demo (sometime in the future builds) to make the game overall stronger!

I see.. so the beat decreases when you get hit. 

Current game's difficulty is totally fine! I am playing the normal difficulty and it's manageable. I usually like to play on easier mode in a story-rich game. So, there isn't much necessary tweaking here.

What I meant by Kiro being disrespectful is just in general sense people are expected to take off their hats inside buildings (maybe it is only a me thing?). Especially here, Kiro is trying to learn from a master, wearing an especially wide hat just shows that he may be hiding something. So it just feels disrespectful to Matsumoto.

Good luck on the development!

(1 edit)

Hi AnonymousRPGDeveloper,

To say from the start, this is a very good RPG! Strong submission!

At the main menu screen, I felt a bit weird greeted with a lo-fi hip-hop beats, because I played lots of jRPGs. But after a while, it became normal, so no problem. The closest thing to existing media from what I can tell is Samurai Champloo. Did you happen to get inspiration from it? It is a bit nitpicky from me.. but currently the game settings and Characters exhibit traditional Japanese samurai. I don't see any character that fit with the lo-fi beats. Perhaps, there will be a new character (some character that is defying or outside of the traditional Japanese culture in the game)  that fit exactly with theme in the next part of the game. In that case, introducing that character in the demo is a must.

Making enemies visible outside of battle do eliminate random encounters that you typically see in older RPGs, however the battles are mostly unavoidable. But the battle is easy to learn and I didn't feel them as hassles, yet. It would be better if there's progression for Kira? (Kiro?) So that it would make the battles more meaningful and it serves well narratively. Just having 1 or 2 tech unlocks for Kiro would be great. Currently every battle doesn't give you anything except occasional healing items and DNA samples. Speaking of DNA sample, why would human enemies also drop them? 🤔

I didn't really understand how you obtain beats to perform the techniques. I must have clicked on too fast to read all the tutorials.

Sprites, characters and the color palette is good! A minor thing that bug is Kiro being a disciple wearing a big field hat feels kinda disrespectful for me.

It took me around 45min to play the whole game. I feel the pacing is a little bit slow for a lot of the game. But I think the slow pacing really put a contrast to the ending. It was a really satisfying ending! Great job on the scenario staging!

Just my 2 cents.. if you want to demo the game, it would be better if the scene is mostly exciting. So I would shorten the first part with Kiro's intro up to the burning house. Not cutting it out entirely, just make the path towards a bit shorter and less enemy battles.

The game is quite polished for still being in early demo. I didn't find any difficulty in navigating all the UI and everything is readable and responsive. Great job!

This is a very strong submission and have the potential to be a great RPG! I hope you will continue on making it and good luck!

(2 edits)

Thank you for checking out the game and leaving an honest feedback!

You gave very fair points. Crowds leaving the player after sun-down was intentional and it can feel betraying if you have just used-up your Fame and they just left suddenly. I'll make sure to communicate it better next time. Maybe not making the gathered leave will be better, I'll try it out in the next prototype.

Oops, I didn't mean for players to think that picking up trash is the main way to gain Fame for Rallying up crowd. My intent is for gaining Fame is by picking up tokens that are generated by establishments. I will make sure to emphasize this more in the on-boarding for future builds.

I do agree that the cafe community screen artwork definitely need serious re-work :D Hopefully it conveyed enough idea visually that you players can improve the cafe as you interact more with it. But it seems the iteration doesn't have compelling reasons for players to visit yet, huh. Will design on it more. So thanks for your comment.

I truly appreciate your word of encouragement and hopefully the project would catch your attention some time in the future when it's in a better state!

Will check out your submission and comment in a bit!
Cheers!