Dude, I am also making a historically based Dungeon Crawler touching on some mysticism. Here's my feedback, and a little offer at the end:
First Bad stuff:
1. The menu/inventory click sound effect is excruciatingly irritating and exhausting. Tires my ears, change the sound completely to be something more satisfying, or add some random pitch variation. It's just a UX thing, simple but meaningful fix(look at how diablo games did it, very satisfying sounds)
2. The same problem with walking player and enemies sound - same pitch, same boring, tiring exhaustion, same fix.
3. THE MOST IMPORTANT: THE MOVE/TURN SPEED IS TIRINGLY SLOW. MAKE IT SNAPPIER! Game feels unresponsive. I just rage-quit the game, it takes forever to finish the move/rotate tween. I tried to turn the animation off that made it even worse. PLEASE add a walking/turn SPEED option/slider in the menu, maybe allow the moves/turns to be instant. I might be perhaps in minority, but the fact I press 3-4 times to move forward or turn, and wait for "eternity" for the turn or movement to finish is EXHAUSTING. That's the biggest turn-off for me in this game. And that leads me to:
4. Not enough custom graphics and gameplay settings. It's nice that there is an FOV slider, but it's not an action game so it's not a priority, while I am irritated by frame drops and slow tween animations that force me to wait until I can perform another action ==> cognitive load for me. Allow me to turn off fancy effects, or change shaders, turn off light sources or sth,
5. Minor: The game runs OK (few rare frame dips) on my intel UHD (it's an old cpu but I still use it even for development, good for debugging such things), but my fans spin like crazy. I suspect the game isn't well optimized and cooks my CPU a little. But it might be the fault of Unity, not yours, but since the game is retro, perhaps you can turn off 90% of unused or redundant engine features that take away from the experience anyway? I would start from using only custom shaders, that eliminate most shading.
6. Minor: I am not a fan of this minecrafty style. Maybe if it were more stylized as retro game, sth like I do with my project Cryptae Spiritus 3D, where it is a mix between Catacomb 3D raycasting, and dithered EGA/VGA pixel art. If you like help with graphics. I CAN HELP YOU. Because I am insane and I like your project. I make music, sounds, I can work in Blender, Krita, Code, make animations, models, you name it. And I have a particular love for 17th century and flintlocks, soooo Just let me know!
Now the Good Stuff:
1. I love the world and lore! I haven't played long enough to know it well but so far, the 17th century, the flintlocks, and everything fits my vibe nicely (although I am not exactly fan of minecrafty look) and there are some mysteries and some stories I can smell behind the corner! This is really hopeful for an immersive RPG! I look really forward to read some of those stories hiding in this 17th century world!
2. The classes! Fascinating!
3. The text fonts and the printout terminal looks amazing and very easy to read! Big Plus!
4. The game UI feels intuitive!
5. Game Mechanics Tried and True, awesome, easy to get into!
6. REALLY Polished Menu --> The Help section, fun and interesting!Didn't expect that, you put a lot of work to!
7. It's nice that you allow to turn without the cost of a turn :)
I hope my feedback is useful, and you will respond. Cheers, mate, and good luck with your project!
Thank you for this! I'll reply to each:
Bad:
- I agree, I wasn't able to find a sound I liked so I added the least bad. Hopefully I'll get a better one.
- Yeah, I need to look into this as well.
- Adjustable walking speed is implemented for the next version with the new default being faster than the current speed. I agree with your points about snappiness, I need to look into this also.
- I need to figure something out for this.
- It's very unoptimized honestly, but it's not a problem for modern computers, but still, I need to start optimizing it.
- Your game looks cool actually! And honestly, I'd prefer my game looking different, but it's a little difficult for me since I want to have it as my personal project as much as possible so even though I'm 100% certain your graphics would be much better and I'd like them more than the current ones, it loses a certain appeal for me if I include other people. I really do appreciate your gesture though, more than I can express.
Good:
- Thanks! Swords, magic, and guns are an underrated combination. I played the first Pillars of Eternity and that essentially resulted in my first game (The Temple of Torment), and this one, having firearms.
- I tried to do something a little different with the classes :).
- Fonts are annoying in general so I'm happy to have found something that has enough pixels but not too many to fit the game.
- Thanks!
- Thanks again!
- Thanks, I thought Help would be useful.
- Of course :). Being ganked from behind and spending two turns to rotate and taking damage makes nobody happy.
Thanks again for these, and good luck with your own!
Thanks for a rich response, I am glad we are on the same page I have high hopes for your project!
In case you changed your mind, my offer still stands. I don't bite, and I do not wish to step over any of your visions, and I can stay faithful to any style you like. Any way, the doors are open, See you some other time then and I wish you all the best of luck with this cool project!