Hey, so I reviewed your game on stream Saturday, the recording is here:
You may also want to check the VOD on twitch before it goes down if you want to see if chat had any additional comment. https://www.twitch.tv/videos/2878537155?t=03h02m45s-Is the battle system intuitive to understand? Is it fun? Too difficult or easy?
As a non-RPG player, no this was not at all intuitive. I did not understand the aggro system nor the speed up mechanic after defending. After rewatching the VOD I think the part that I was missing is that the aggro system is a percentage of 100 shared between the members of the party. This was never explained, and since there was no percent symbol it was completely lost on me. But your tutorial explained that "aggro goes up from attacking, and goes down from defending" which is untrue. It ALSO goes down when your ally attacks, which needs to be expressed in some capacity as I never understood that. Even after rewatching I did not understand how I was supposed to determine turn order after speed ups, as I had times where units went in unexpected orders and saw no indicator for speed.
-Is the story compelling? Are there any objectionable or clunky moments?
I didn't really get far enough in to really comment on the story. The writing seemed fine to me. I did feel like that intro dragged on for a really long time considering all that happened was "student asks to study under master, master accepts."
-Is the music enjoyable? Does it fit the tone of the game?
Yes, the music was probably my favorite part. Unfortunately I had to practically mute it, as the grating chimes that roll out during text were unbearable. They are a big pet peeve of mine and since I turned up the SFX before I started and couldn't lower them during the intro, I played practically muted.
-Are the sprites well made? Does anything stand out as needing to be changed?
Sprites/art looked really well done. Overall I like the muted palette, but in places it was a bit much. Like the masters dojo was just brown on brown, since that is the introduction to the game having that little visual intrigue is maybe not advisable.