Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines
(+1)

Hey, so I reviewed your game on stream Saturday, the recording is here: 

You may also want to check the VOD on twitch before it goes down if you want to see if chat had any additional comment. https://www.twitch.tv/videos/2878537155?t=03h02m45s

-Is the battle system intuitive to understand? Is it fun? Too difficult or easy?

As a non-RPG player, no this was not at all intuitive. I did not understand the aggro system nor the speed up mechanic after defending. After rewatching the VOD I think the part that I was missing is that the aggro system is a percentage of 100 shared between the members of the party. This was never explained, and since there was no percent symbol it was completely lost on me. But your tutorial explained that "aggro goes up from attacking, and goes down from defending" which is untrue. It ALSO goes down when your ally attacks, which needs to be expressed in some capacity as I never understood that. Even after rewatching I did not understand how I was supposed to determine turn order after speed ups, as I had times where units went in unexpected orders and saw no indicator for speed.

-Is the story compelling? Are there any objectionable or clunky moments?

I didn't really get far enough in to really comment on the story. The writing seemed fine to me. I did feel like that intro dragged on for a really long time considering all that happened was "student asks to study under master, master accepts." 

-Is the music enjoyable? Does it fit the tone of the game?

Yes, the music was probably my favorite part. Unfortunately I had to practically mute it, as the grating chimes that roll out during text were unbearable. They are a big pet peeve of mine and since I turned up the SFX before I started and couldn't lower them during the intro, I played practically muted. 

-Are the sprites well made? Does anything stand out as needing to be changed? 

Sprites/art looked really well done. Overall I like the muted palette, but in places it was a bit much. Like the masters dojo was just brown on brown, since that is the introduction to the game having that little visual intrigue is maybe not advisable. 

(+1)

Thanks a lot for playing!

I really appreciate you putting in the effort to really try and understand the combat. It's really common for streamers to breeze past vital info while they play and then find themselves stumped on mechanics, but it's really clear that wasn't the case here and you really did your best, which gives me a ton of valuable data for improving that.

Just to clear up some of the misconceptions about the timeline mechanics, a lot of the confusion seems to have stemmed from Matsumoto's Ground Cleave skill having a "Wait" stat, which means after selecting the attack the user will wait a small while before executing the skill. This isn't explained at all in this portion of the game, so perhaps giving the player a skill that is affected by that mechanic just further adds to the confusion. As for successful Guarding speeding you up, what that really means is that the guarding character is automatically moved closer to the edge of the timeline straight away; this does not actually affect the rate at which their gauge goes up after that point. I'll look into how that could be rephrased since that's a pretty important mechanic as well. I'm open to suggestions you might have as well with that context!

With your mouse cursor vanishing, that is indeed due to your playing on Gamepad. Steam has a soft requirement that the mouse cursor is hidden for games utilizing the gamepad, and I didn't anticipate players would want to use their mouse cursor while playing with a gamepad anyway, so it becomes hidden when gamepad input is used and appears again if the player clicks inside the window. This might be a niche case since you wanted to use the cursor for illustrative purposes during playtesting, but that confusion nevertheless feels worth addressing.

On the subject of the ambiguity with the Aggro and Speed mechanics, I wonder if simply adding a percent sign next to those UI elements would minimize the confusion. In either case, while turn order can be predicted with perfect accuracy, right now it's a lot harder to anticipate how Aggro shifts when attacks are used, which I definitely think is important.

I'll have to wait on further feedback regarding the story, it's my understanding this isn't a genre that you usually enjoy, so it would probably be unwise for me to go scorched earth and trim down the narrative when that is the core appeal for most fans of the genre. I certainly wouldn't go so far as to describe the story as "fluff" as was mentioned on the stream, but I am very receptive to the idea of trimming the narrative down a bit, as long as that doesn't come at the expense of the characters and writing that most players are here for. There is likely a balance that can improve the experience for everyone.

This was very helpful data, and I appreciate it! Of course, I also fixed that bug at the end, that was an oversight on my part due to the way the anonymous builds updated, but it should be gone as soon as the next update. Thanks a lot for playing!

(+1)

Thanks, I did try my best, but I didn't figure out the aggro split until after my stream. It can be really easy to miss things while streaming.

Ah, yes, I did not realize there was a wait mechanic. I might suggest having the top ability be completely basic just to have a baseline. 

I think my only idea with visualizing the speed up would be what I suggested during stream. If I could see future turns on the timeline, like maybe even slightly faded future 1,2, A, Bs so that I knew what was coming up. And then that would show the default position, but when you hover a guard skill, you would see it move forward in the timeline. That would really help convey what that means. 

I think a % symbol would get me there eventually, and a single extra line in your aggro tutorial explaining that it is shared or balanced between team members would solidify it completely.

I certainly agree, I would not make any story changes based solely off my feedback. The intro fight was just a smidge past the point where I get antsy, so I assume RPG fans would have been happy with that pacing. I do think there is probably a way to make the intro a bit more interesting, but I would defer to your ideas and other feedback you get.