Hi, thanks for the detailed feedback, much appreciated!
If we managed to make some of our players mad during their visit to our little asylum, it's an achievement by itself (:
I understand the frustration regarding the controls, this is a part of the game's challenge and general theme, and probably not everybody's cup of tea, but 'not trusting' our initial gaming reflexes and intuition is what we were aiming for with it. We will add controller support and WASD in the next version, but keep in mind that those will require the same mental adjustments.
As for the other issues:
- The lack of walls is intentional, but the design of the level and additional levels may vary, so having some walls at certain areas is an option.
- I agree with your note about checkpoints, we didn't manage to implement them in the timeframe of the jam, but they will be there in future versions.
- Regarding having certain elements interactable and other not and having to take risks to find out, this is a part of the theme of the game and the jam and general.
- The Comma and period keys are used to switch the order of the party members if you have more than one party member (they don't do anything when there's only one character). The other one is Backspace, not Enter, and it is used to leave party members behind.
- As for the hopping sound, your suggestion is already implemented in the game - as there are several audio clips for hopping and for landing, and the same sound never plays twice in a row. I will double check that anyway.
Viewing post in Mental Trap jam comments
Then I'd venture to say that the design philosophy of this game might not bode well for its longevity. The struggle from this genre of game doesn't usually come from the controls being counterintuitive but rather overengineered (I am bread) or oversimplified (Getting over it). A lot of people in the comments mentioned the controls being jarring. I'd just take note of that.
As for the level design and "having players take risks to find out" if things are interactable or not, I'd caution you to reminisce on that and verify that's actually what you want. This is a pattern many devs fall into and it ruins games. Someone, like myself, will try interacting with a poster to see what secret dialogue the devs left for us only to die the first few times then genuinely stop trying. For the rest of the game, after they've been trained not to interact with anything, players will ignore anything you leave around. This is something the lead designer of Civilization IV, Soren Johnson, commented on once: “Given the opportunity, players will optimize the fun out of a game.” If the cost of dying and retracing one's steps to get back to where they were outweighs the possibility for interacting with something, players will take the optimal path and just ignore it.