.... spoiler speculation...
Maybe.
The Offense can also be a succes, but Gladius or some other Squire(s) gets killed or crippled. This would be rather a drama build-up instead of an instant escalation like in a movie. Calbex and some Squire are angriy at Fen, but Central Command does not care about losses of Squires as long as Commander Fen wins.
I doubt the Knights lose a battle because 4-12 Squires cannot handle a situation. After all the Knights do most of the work.